Essays In Pastoral MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
Essays In Pastoral Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
First aid in illness and injury; Medicine
In many conditions where the nervous system can have influence a
miracle is very difficult of proof from the context. There can, of
course, be evident miracles in the cure of some nervous disorders,
supposing the diagnosis to be certain. The sudden cure of advanced
paresis would be as much a miracle as the sudden replacing of a lost
femur. Commonly, however, in neuroses if there is an apparently
miraculous healing or similar effect, the supernatural quality can not
be established. Suppose Bernadette reported that she had seen the
Blessed Virgin at Lourdes: the only safe thing to do in such a case is
to deny the apparition until it has been proved. Suppose, secondly,
that a patient who has been confined to bed for years by an hysterical
paralysis, believed in the reality of the vision, had himself carried
to Lourdes, and while at prayer there he suddenly stood up cured. That
effect would prove neither the reality of the vision nor the
supernatural quality of the cure; nor would it disprove either. We
simply can not judge the case, because exactly the same effect has
happened hundreds of times from purely natural impressions. If that
same paralytic were lying in his bed at home and you set the house
afire he would jump up and run.
If the patient, however, had been bedridden with a paralysis caused by
certain degeneration of nervous tissue, and he were cured in the
manner described, that effect would be supernatural, miraculous;
always provided there is no error in the medical diagnosis.
There is a genuine diabetes and a pseudodiabetes. The latter condition
may be diagnosed as true diabetes by a number of physicians, but it is
only a symptom of hysteria. If the pseudodiabetes is suddenly cured,
this cure may or may not be miraculous, but no one can say which is
the truth; the probability is a hundred to one that the cure is
altogether natural. There was a flourishing Christian Science
congregation established in the west recently upon "miraculous" cure
of a case of pseudodiabetes, which some ignorant physicians had called
true diabetes, notwithstanding the fact that Christian Science does
not believe in either diabetes or false diabetes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account