Essays In Pastoral MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
Essays In Pastoral Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
First aid in illness and injury; Medicine
A very interesting phase of social medicine is the ease and confidence
displayed by people, often of more than ordinary intelligence, in
recommending various proprietary medicines of which they know nothing
except the fact that someone says he, or more often she, was cured of
something or other by their use. A chance remark like this to a
sufferer becomes a high recommendation. The hardest problem the doctor
has before him is to find out what is really the matter with his
patients. Not infrequently people having apparently the same set of
symptoms are suffering from quite different {92} ailments. A symptom
like a sore throat, for instance, may very well be due to any one of
at least a half-dozen of causes, most of which require their own
peculiar treatment. When the affection under consideration is as
indefinite as a tired feeling, or indigestion, or some one of the many
ailments included under the term biliousness or kidney trouble, from
which people are supposed to suffer, then the diagnosis problem
becomes by far the most serious question in the case, and is often
very difficult. The trained physician prudently hesitates, but the
inexpert in medicine steps in and quite volubly announces what the
ailment is in his opinion, and what will probably do it good. A little
knowledge is indeed a dangerous thing in medical matters. If it be
remembered that there is a very general impression among medical men
now, as the result of recent acquisitions of scientific information
with regard to the origin, pathological basis, and course of disease,
that very probably more harm than good has been done by the
administration of medicines in the past, not only the futility of lay
(or clerical) prescribing will be manifest, but also somewhat of the
amount of harm that may be done.
It is often a matter for painful surprise, then, to find that
clergymen and members of religious communities allow their names to be
used in the recommendation of remedies of whose composition they know
nothing, for a disease of which they know less, if possible. This evil
becomes especially poignant when the columns of our reputable
religious press are allowed to be used for the purpose of exploiting
the public in these matters. The remedies most often recommended are
the so-called tonics. These are best represented by the sarsaparillas,
and by various cures for catarrh, indigestion, and kindred indefinite
ills, of which there are a great many on the market. These are not
secret remedies, since their composition is well known by those of the
medical profession who care to secure the information. Some six years
ago an analysis of most of them was made by the Massachusetts State
Board of Health. [Footnote 1]
[Footnote 1: 28th Annual Report Mass. Board of Health; food and drug
inspection, 1897.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account