Essays in Zen Buddhism : $b First seriesSuzuki, Daisetz Teitaro
Religion
Essays in Zen Buddhism : $b First series
Suzuki, Daisetz Teitaro
Zen Buddhism
When Jōshu asked Kwanchu (Tai-tz‘u Huan-chung)[6.40] of the ninth
century, “What is the being [or substance] of Prajñā?” Kwanchu
without giving any answer simply echoed the question, “What is the
being of Prajñā?” And this brought out a hearty laugh on the part of
Jōshu. Prajñā may be translated supreme intelligence, and Mañjuśrī is
regarded by the Mahayanists as the embodiment of Prajñā. But in this
case Mañjuśrī has nothing to do with it. The question is concerned
with the substantial conception of Prajñā, which, being a form of
mental activity, requires something to abide in. According to Buddhist
philosophy, there are three fundamental conceptions to explain the
problem of existence: Substance or Being (_bhāva_), Appearance or
Aspect (_lakshaṇa_), and Function or Activity (_kṛitya_). Or, to
use the terms of the _Mādhyamika_, the three conceptions are actor,
act, and acting. Prajñā being an intellectual acting, there must be
an agent or substance back of it. Hence the question: What is the
being or body of Prajñā? Now, the answer or echo given out by Kwanchu
does not explain anything, we are at a loss as far as its conceptual
signification goes. The Zen masters do not give us any literary clue
to get around what we see on the surface. When we try to understand
it intellectually, it slips away from us. It must be approached
therefore from another plane of unconsciousness. Unless we move on to
the same plane where the masters stand, or unless we abandon so-called
common-sense way of reasoning, there is no possible bridge which will
carry us over the chasm dividing our intellection from their apparently
psittacine repetitions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account