There is little patriotic feeling in "Sevastopol," and its success was
artistic rather than political. Of course Russian courage is praised,
but so is the courage of the French. In spite of the fact that Tolstoi
was a Russian officer, actively fighting for his country, he shows a
singular aloofness from party passion in all his descriptions. The
only partisan statement is in the half sentence, "it is a comfort to
think that it was not we who began this war, that we are only
defending our own country," which might profitably be read by those
who believe in "just" wars, along with Tennyson's "Maud," published at
the same time. Tennyson was cock-sure that the English were God's own
people, and in all this bloodshed were doing the blessed work of their
Father in heaven.
"God's just wrath shall be wreak'd on a giant liar."
Throughout the heat of the conflict, Tolstoi felt its utter absurdity,
really holding the same views of war that he held as an old man. "And
why do not Christian people," he wrote in "Sevastopol in May," "who
profess the one great law of love and self-sacrifice, when they behold
what they have wrought, fall in repentance upon their knees before Him
who, when He gave them life, implanted in the soul of each of them,
together with the fear of death, a love of the good and beautiful,
and, with tears of joy and happiness, embrace each other like
brothers?"
Together with the fear of death-this fear is analysed by Tolstoi in
all its manifestations. The fear of the young officer, as he exchanges
the enthusiastic departure from Petersburg for the grim reality of the
bastions; the fear of the still sound and healthy man as he enters the
improvised hospitals; the fear as the men watch the point of
approaching light that means a shell; the fear of the men lying on the
ground, waiting with closed eyes for the shell to burst. It is the
very psychology of death. In reading the account of Praskukhin's
sensations just before death, one feels, as one does in reading the
thoughts of Anna Karenina under the train, that Tolstoi himself must
have died in some previous existence, in order to analyse death so
clearly. And all these officers, who walk in the Valley of the Shadow,
have their selfish ambitions, their absurd social distinctions, and
their overweening, egotistical vanity.
At the end of the middle sketch, "Sevastopol in May," Tolstoi wrote
out the only creed to which he remained consistently true all his
life, the creed of Art.
"Who is the villain, who the hero? All are good and all are evil.
"The hero of my tale, whom I love with all the strength of my soul,
whom I have tried to set forth in all his beauty, and who has always
been, is, and always will be most beautiful, is--the truth."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account