Essays Upon Heredity and Kindred Biological Problems: Authorised TranslationWeismann, August
Science
Essays Upon Heredity and Kindred Biological Problems: Authorised Translation
Weismann, August
Evolution (Biology); Genetics; Reproduction
It may be objected that cells of which the ancestors possessed the
power of living for ever, could not become potentially mortal (that is
subject to death from internal causes) either suddenly or gradually,
for such a change would contradict the supposition which attributes
immortality to their ancestors and to the products of their division.
This argument is valid, but it only applies so long as the descendants
retain the original constitution. But as soon as the two products of
the fission of a potentially immortal cell acquire different
constitutions by unequal fission, another possibility arises. Now it is
conceivable that one of the products of fission might preserve the
physical constitution necessary for immortality, but not the other;
just as it is conceivable that such a cell—adapted for unending
life—might bud off a small part, which would live a long time without
the full capabilities of life possessed by the parent cell; again, it
is possible that such a cell might extrude a certain amount of organic
matter (a true excretion) which is already dead at the moment it leaves
the body. Thus it is possible that true unequal cell-division, in which
only one half possesses the condition necessary for increasing, may
take place; and in the same way it is conceivable that the constitution
of a cell determines the fixed duration of its life, examples of which
are before us in the great number of cells in the higher Metazoa, which
are destroyed by their functions. The more specialized a cell becomes,
or in other words, the more it is intrusted with only one distinct
function, the more likely is this to be the case: who then can tell us,
whether the limited duration of life was brought about in consequence
of the restricted functions of the cell or whether it was determined by
other advantages[84]? In either case we must maintain that the
disadvantages arising from a limited duration of the cells are more
than compensated for by the advantages which result from their highly
effective specialized functions. Although no one of the functions of
the body is necessarily attended by the limited duration of the cells
which perform it, as is proved by the persistence of unicellular forms,
yet any or all of them might lead to such a limitation of existence
without in any way injuring the species, as is proved by the Metazoa.
But the reproductive cells cannot be limited in this way, and they
alone are free from it. They could not lose their immortality, if
indeed the Metazoa are derived from the immortal Protozoa, for from the
very nature of that immortality it cannot be lost. From this point of
view the body, or _soma_, appears in a certain sense as a secondary
appendage of the real bearer of life,—the reproductive cells.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account