Essays Upon Heredity and Kindred Biological Problems: Authorised TranslationWeismann, August
Science
Essays Upon Heredity and Kindred Biological Problems: Authorised Translation
Weismann, August
Evolution (Biology); Genetics; Reproduction
My opinion as to the behaviour of the idioplasm during ontogeny, not
only differs from that of Nägeli, in that the latter maintains that the
idioplasm only undergoes changes in its ‘conditions of tension and
movement,’ but also because he imagines this substance to be composed
of the preformed germs of structures (‘Anlagen’). Nägeli’s views are
obviously bound up with his theory of a continuous network of idioplasm
throughout the whole body; perhaps he would have adopted other
conclusions had he been aware of the fact that the idioplasm must only
be sought for in the nuclei. Nägeli’s views as to ontogeny can be best
seen in the following passages: ‘As soon as ontogenetic development
begins, the groups of micellae in the idioplasm which effect the first
stage of development, enter upon active growth: such activity causes a
passive growth of the other groups, and an increase in the whole
idioplasm, perhaps to many times its former bulk. But the intensities
of growth in the two series of groups are unequal, and consequently an
increasing tension is produced which sooner or later, according to the
number, arrangement, and energy of the active groups, necessarily
renders the continuation of the process impossible. In consequence of
such disturbance to the equilibrium, active growth now takes place in
the next group, leading to fresh irritation, and this group then reacts
more strongly than all the others upon the tension which first
stimulated its activity. These changes are repeated until all the
groups are gone through, and the ontogenetic development finally
reaches the stage at which propagation takes place, and thus the
original stage of the germ is reached.’
Hence, according to Nägeli, the different stages of ontogeny arise out
of the activities of different parts of the idioplasm: certain groups
of micellae in the idioplasm represent the germs (‘Anlagen’) of certain
structures in the organism: when any such germ reacts under stimulation
it produces the corresponding structure. It seems to me that this
hypothesis bears some resemblance to Darwin’s theory of pangenesis. I
think that Nägeli’s preformed germs of structures (‘Anlagen’) and his
groups of such germs are highly elaborated equivalents of the gemmules
of pangenesis, which, according to Darwin, manifest activity when their
turn comes, or, according to Nägeli, when they react under stimulation.
When a group of such germs, by their active growth or by their
‘irritation,’ have caused a similar active growth or a similar
irritation in the next group, the former may come to rest, or may
remain in a state of activity together with its successor, for a longer
or shorter period. Its activity may even last for an unlimited time, as
is the case in the formation of leafy shoots in many plants.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account