Essays Upon Some Controverted QuestionsHuxley, Thomas Henry
Religion
Essays Upon Some Controverted Questions
Huxley, Thomas Henry
Science
any foundation of reality that may exist is submerged beneath the
imaginative superstructure.
At present, however, I am not concerned to dwell upon the importance of
fictitious literature and the immensity of the work which it has effected
in the education of the human race. I propose to deal with the much more
limited inquiry: Are there two other classes of consecutive narratives (as
distinct from statements of individual facts), or only one? Is there any
known historical work which is throughout exactly true, or is there not? In
the case of the great majority of histories the answer is not doubtful:
they are all only partially true. Even those venerable works which bear the
names of some of the greatest of ancient Greek and Roman writers, and which
have been accepted by generation after generation, down to modern times, as
stores of unquestionable truth, have been compelled by scientific
criticism, after a long battle, to descend to the common level, and to
confess to a large admixture of error. I might {504} fairly take this for
granted; but it may be well that I should entrench myself behind the very
apposite words of a historical authority who is certainly not obnoxious to
even a suspicion of sceptical tendencies.
Time was--and that not very long ago--when all the relations of ancient
authors concerning the old world were received with a ready belief; and
an unreasoning and uncritical faith accepted with equal satisfaction
the narrative of the campaigns of Cæsar and of the doings of Romulus,
the account of Alexander's marches and of the conquests of Semiramis.
We can most of us remember when, in this country, the whole story of
regal Rome, and even the legend of the Trojan settlement in Latium,
were seriously placed before boys as history, and discoursed of as
unhesitatingly and in as dogmatic a tone as the tale of the Catiline
Conspiracy or the Conquest of Britain....
But all this is now changed. The last century has seen the birth and
growth of a new science--the Science of Historical Criticism.... The
whole world of profane history has been revolutionised....[142]
If these utterances were true when they fell from the lips of a Bampton
lecturer in 1859, with how much greater force do they appeal to us now,
when the immense labours of the generation now passing away constitute one
vast illustration of the power and fruitfulness of scientific methods of
investigation in history, no less than in all other departments of
knowledge.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account