Excursions to Cairo, Jerusalem, Damascus, and Balbec From the United States Ship Delaware, During Her Recent Cruise: With an Attempt to Discriminate Between Truth and Error in Regard to the Sacred Places of the Holy CityJones, George
History
Excursions to Cairo, Jerusalem, Damascus, and Balbec From the United States Ship Delaware, During Her Recent Cruise: With an Attempt to Discriminate Between Truth and Error in Regard to the Sacred Places of the Holy City
Jones, George
Middle East -- Description and travel
I cannot, however, join in the frequent outcry of imposition, craft
and falsehood against the sects who hold these places, and recite
these traditions to the visitor. That such things as these are to be
found in high and sacred seats, is doubtless true, and that they are
sometimes practised here is also very probable; but I can find, for a
great many of these traditions, an origin of a more charitable nature,
and I believe one more consonant with the real state of the case. We
live now in an age of light and knowledge, and find it hard even to
imagine the darkness that once covered Europe and all these lands. We
can form only some idea of it from the books of the middle ages--books
full of fable and false philosophy on every subject. These fables on
medicine, on alchemy, on astrology, and on a multitude of other topics,
grew up, we are willing to believe, from men’s ignorance; in some cases
there may have been deliberate deception; but in most, their origin was
in the gross ignorance of the times; they show the strivings of minds
shorn of their strength by diseases hereditary and for ages universal;
men saw but dimly, and wandered into the ways of error when really
and honestly in search of truth. And if we are willing to extend
this charity to the other sciences, why not also to that of religion,
where men’s feelings are apt to be more warmly affected, and even in a
good cause, to warp the judgment, particularly if it be weak, than in
any other? In this very city, the Mahomedans have a great variety of
traditions with respect to the mosque of Omar, and some other of their
sacred places about Jerusalem, quite as wild as any thing among the
Christian sects; yet when we listen to them, we do not at once cry out
“craft and roguery,” and believe the narrator to be wilfully imposing
on us. We are willing to suppose him honest. We look at him; his face
is grave; he has the appearance of sincerity; and we attribute the
error to the deep and dark ignorance in which these people are known to
live. Now I wish to claim for the Christian traditions just what we are
willing to give to those of the Mahomedans. The principle of charity
may, it is true, be carried too far, but I wish to see it carried
further than it is. Let us go among these sacred places cautious,
as cautious as you choose; but not sneering, or cultivating bitter
feelings towards one another; let us pity the ignorance of our brother
and commiserate him, but not load him with harsh epithets. Uncharitable
insinuations are certainly very much out of place in this region, which
should excite only humble and tender feelings; where, amid tauntings
and contumely showered upon him, the Saviour prayed, “Father, forgive
them, _for they know not what they do_.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account