Later (1903) the _dramatis personæ_ are a man in East Islington
jumping on his wife, and a woman in West Islington stabbing her
husband. But this argument, of course, will not hold. For it is the
same men who denounce wounds made (under anæsthetics) for physiology,
and who make wounds (without anæsthetics) in sport.
3. It says that the "object" of the sportsman is to kill; but the
"object" of the experimenter is to torture:--
"There is a vast difference between the killing of animals and
the torturing of them before killing them. The object of the
sportsman is to kill his quarry; the object of the vivisector is
to keep his victim alive while he dissects it."--Mr. Wood
(1903).
"The object of the sportsman is to kill, and the object of the
vivisector is to keep his victim alive while he cuts it
up."--Lord Llangattock (1901).
"The vivisector is nothing if not a tormentor; the sportsman is
not a true sportsman if he seeks to inflict pain on his
quarry.... One (the pain of a horse falling on asphalt) is the
result of an accident to be deplored, the other (the pain from
an experiment) is done of devilish malice prepense."--Leader in
the Society's official journal, (1899).
"I am not so mentally and ethically confused as to be unable to
distinguish between the entirely different moral acts of killing
and torturing."--Mr. Coleridge (1901).
Here are four statements. One is by Mr. Wood, the Society's lecturer;
one by Lord Llangattock, its President; one is published in its
official journal; and one is by Mr. Coleridge, its honorary secretary
and treasurer. That is the sort of thing which seems good enough to
the National Society to say to its friends in Parliament; this
childish nonsense about the true sportsman and his quarry.
III
The attitude of these Societies toward the medical profession, and
toward the Hospitals, must be studied. Let us look through some
numbers of the official journal of the National Society, and see the
attitude that it sometimes takes toward the medical profession:--
_June 1899._--"The charm of this sort of thing is that you are
always sure of the _post-mortem_ if of nothing else."
_July 1899._--"There is a disease, well known to the vestrymen
of London, called 'the half-crown diphtheria.' This is common
sore throat, notified as diphtheria because the vestry pays a
fee of half-a-crown to the medical notifier."
_December 1899._--"The patient died, made miserable by the
effect of inoculations which even on bacteriological grounds
gave no promise of success, but the scientific physician,
nowadays, must inject something in the way of a serum."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account