Unlike the greater number of Italian composers, whose highest aim was a
cheerful, agreeably stimulating artistic enjoyment, there is in Cherubini
an element of severity, an aristocratic elegance of expression, which
often border on coldness. Strains such as enchant the multitude are of
infrequent occurrence in his music. It is, therefore, not to be wondered
at that the multitude kept itself aloof from him. Only one of all his
operas, "Les Deux Journées," now known in Germany under the name of
"Der Wasserträger" (The Water Carrier), was able to attain a lasting
popularity. For a variety of reasons, also, his sacred compositions
have failed to become widely known. The masses and requiems are, first
of all, too grand and earnest, too difficult and full of meaning, to
adapt themselves to the vapid style of Catholic Church music, and, when
performed in the concert room, they do not often produce their full
effect. Nor is the three-part writing, which Cherubini has repeatedly
employed with reference to the needs of the French church choirs,
at all suited to the requirements of our choral societies. It is,
unfortunately, too often the case that trifling obstacles of a similar
character interfere with a proper appreciation of the finest productions
of genius. The fact that the name of Cherubini does not stand inscribed
in the temple of fame with those of Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven must be
attributed in some degree to unfamiliarity with his works on the part
of the public, but is still further owing to the peculiarity of the
artist's musical nature, and to the remarkable place which he has created
for himself in and beyond the musical life of the nations. To estimate
him at his full value should be the distinctive office of the German
people; and it is indeed true that, while he is everywhere spoken of with
respect, there exists to-day, in the select circle of German musicians
and musical critics, as little doubt as existed five-and-twenty years ago
that a place should be accorded to Cherubini among the greatest composers
whom the world has known. He mastered musical forms and resources to
an extent that has been rarely equalled. In the severe contrapuntal
style of composition, which has gone more and more out of fashion since
Beethoven, he surpassed all his contemporaries, whatever might be
their relations to him in other respects. With the single exception of
Sebastian Bach, no composer has ever employed the contrapuntal forms so
freely, intelligently, and profoundly as Cherubini; while as regards
harmony and transparent clearness, he stands even before Bach in the most
complicated of his works. A thorough mastery of counterpoint is of more
especial importance in vocal church music, although dramatic composition
also affords it sufficient opportunity, and it can nowhere be entirely
dispensed with. In addition to his skill in this direction, Cherubini had
complete control over the technique and the forms of modern instrumental
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account