In closing this estimate of Verdi as a composer of opera, we may add
that even in his most absolute departure from the traditions of Italian
opera, as he found them, he has remained essentially Italian. It has
been argued that in his later works he falls under the sway of Wagner;
but this, we think, would be difficult to demonstrate. He may not have
remained uninfluenced by the German master's theories regarding the
character of opera librettos, but musically, he is always a true son of
his native land. His younger Italian contemporaries have far outrun him
as reformers. From present indications it would appear that Verdi is
destined to be the last of the long line of Italian opera composers whose
theories were those of the old school, more or less modified in respect
to style or fashion, as time passed. He has had no imitators and he will
leave no disciples. In this he will also be singular, for from the dawn
of opera to the present time every great composer of Italian opera has
left behind him a survivor who has followed in his footsteps--at least
until he has found out an individual path for himself. From the era
when Nicolo Logroscino invented the concerted _finale_ for comic opera,
and it was first extended to serious opera by Pasiello, Italian serious
opera began to break away from its earlier rigid form and to congeal into
that which prevailed down to the period when the reform, with which we
have just dealt, gave to it a death blow. From Pasiello and Piccinni,
composer after composer appeared, each succeeding one overlapping his
immediate predecessor and carrying the development of the school a step
farther. Cimarosa followed Piccinni in this way, and was in turn followed
by Rossini, who was succeeded by Mercadante, Pacini, Bellini, Donizetti
and Verdi. Here, as we have already observed, the line abruptly ends,
and not with the greatest of the brilliant group. Which, if any, of
Verdi's operas will survive it is difficult to predict, but we think
that "Rigoletto" has the best chance; but none of them is destined to
the immortality of "La Serva Padrona," "Il Matrimonio Segreto," "La
Sonnambula" and "Il Barbiere di Siviglia."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account