The particular and very uncertain success of Mascagni's second opera,
"Amico Fritz," was a great disappointment to those who had looked upon
the young author as a coming king in the realm of opera. But the great
triumph of his third work, "I Rantzau," produced at Florence in November,
1892, has revived the hope that Mascagni is not merely a lucky child
of fortune, but that he possesses an out-spoken musical and dramatic
individuality. That he is only an opera composer is beyond a doubt. The
sudden changes in stage situation, the sharp contrasts, and, above all,
the musical scene-painting which he does with coarse but sure brush,
these are factors whose fitness to the genius of Mascagni stamps him as
wholly in the trend of his theatrical talent. The chief significance
of the new opera, "I Rantzau," lies, in our opinion, in the fact that
Mascagni has at last composed something which seems to be the product of
a personal and characteristic style.
There are two other composers whose reputations are still young, one of
whom, Giordano, has been brought to public attention through the Sonzogno
competition. The other, Leoncavallo, a man of literary as well as musical
gifts, was able to choose the most practical way of introducing himself
as an operatic composer, by paying the expenses of the performance of
his opera, "I Pagliacci," at the Teatro del Verme in Milan. The work
had an almost unparalleled success. We may well believe that this opera
will, in the course of time, enjoy even greater popularity than attended
its fortunate twin sister, "Cavalleria Rusticana." Leoncavallo himself
wrote the text of his opera. Giordano treated another sketch of the Verga
collection. In this work, "Malavita," he displays all the qualities
required by an operatic composer--rapid musical development, broadly
melodious phrasing, great variety of coloring, and vivid, sparkling
rhythm, both in vocal and instrumental writing. There is every hope
that Giordano, if his further artistic and musical development should
fully realize its brilliant promise, may one day rank among the most
prominent of Italian stage composers. But neither Mascagni nor Giordano
can reach the surprising and striking originality found in Leoncavallo's
"Pagliacci." W. von Sachs, a well-known New York critic, attended in
Vienna a performance of "Pagliacci," and we have from him the opinion
that Ruggero Leoncavallo may be called the head of the new Milanese
school of composers. The plot, founded partly on the "Drama Nuevo" of
Estibanez, and in its essential details not unlike the French play
"Tabarin," presents the oft tried experiment of a play within a play.
The hero is a mountebank who, deceived by his faithless wife, enacts in
earnest the mimic scenes of jealousy. The principal characters, five in
number, as in the "Cavalleria," belong, with one exception, to a company
of strolling players, who, in the typical roles of the old Italian
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account