As is readily conceivable, when we consider the school in which his taste
was formed, Handel wrote from preference chamber music in the Italian
style. He has given us solo sonatas with bass, trios for two violins and
bass, _concerti grossi_, and concertos for the organ. But here, also,
he shows an inclination to depart from the forms which, after a gradual
process of development, had become established in 1700, not for the
purpose of making organic improvement in them, but through pure caprice.
Like that of his piano compositions, the music has something of an
improvisatorial and accidental character. It might be different, without
becoming therefore less beautiful and entertaining. The creations which
he offers are by no means always original; we repeatedly find portions
of his compositions for the voice, which he has simply arranged for
instruments. He once went with a clerical friend of his to take a walk
in the Vauxhall gardens on the Thames, at the hour of the usual public
concert. The orchestra began to play and both men drew near to listen.
After a time the old clergyman said: "It is wretched stuff." "You are
right," said Handel, "I thought so myself, after I had written it." But
just in this improvisatorial style lies one of the especial charms of his
instrumental music. It is necessarily unequal in merit, but when the
composer was in the right mood, he accomplished something which delighted
everybody and will always delight anew. Among the twelve _concerti
grossi_ of 1739, the third, in E minor, and the sixth, in G minor, are
works of surpassing beauty. The twelve _concerti_ are only written
for stringed instruments, to which Handel, for the most part confines
himself in works of a different class. This is the Italian fashion.
Bach employs by preference the most diverse sorts of wind instruments
in the six great concertos of 1721. To his complex, contrapuntal style
of writing, moreover, the transparent simplicity of Handel, who always
says exactly what he has to say without circumlocution, but with the
greatest emphasis, offers a sharp contrast. One may say, indeed, that
Handel's _concerti grossi_ are no _concerti_ at all, in Bach's sense of
the word. They have the form of Corelli's sonatas, freely adapted to the
resources of a fuller body of instruments. The organ concertos of Handel
are more in the prescribed form. It has already been observed that the
organ is here treated like a piano of richer tone, and not like a church
instrument, after the manner of Bach. English performers have had the
same idea and have just as often made use of the concertos for piano
music.
[Illustration: Fac-simile autograph manuscript of passage from Handel's
"Messiah."]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account