The reader may have wondered why the frescoes in the chapel of the
palace have not yet been mentioned; “where,” writes Vasari, “Giotto
depicted amongst others, as can be seen to-day, Dante Alighieri, his
contemporary and very great friend, no less famous as a poet than was
Giotto as a painter.” The theory is that Giotto painted the chapel in
1295, or between 1300 and 1304 when Florence was at peace, thanks to
the mediation of the Pope’s Legate, Cardinal Aquasparta. Now every one
acquainted with Florentine history knows that the city was then in a
state of internecine warfare and that the well-intentioned efforts of
the Cardinal were abortive. The Bianchi were driven out in 1302 when
furious faction fights ensued between the “Grandi” and the “Neri,”
or popular party, ending in the murder of Corso Donati. The Italian
translation of the old chronicler Filippo Villani’s booklet, _De
origine civitatis Florentiae et eiusdem famosis civibus_, is often
quoted to prove that the portrait of Dante is by Giotto; it says:
“He, [Giotto] painted himself, by the aid of a looking-glass, and his
contemporary the poet Dante Alighieri in the chapel of the palace of
the Podestà, on the wall.” Now the original Latin text runs: _pinxit
insuper speculorum suffragio semetipsum sibique contemporaneum Dantem
IN TABULA alteris cappelle palatii potestatis_, that is to say, he
painted his own and Dante’s portrait in the altar picture on panel.
This picture was still extant in 1382, as it is mentioned in an
inventory then made of the contents of the palace. Many other cogent
reasons, too long to quote here, against the possibility of the fresco
being by Giotto are given by Milanesi, in his notes to Vasari’s life of
Giotto, and both he and Passerini agree that no mural paintings could
have survived the terrible fire which devastated the building in 1332.
The altar picture, on the other hand, must have been saved, or it would
not have been mentioned by Filippo Villani, or be in the inventory.
Signor Milanesi suggests that it was painted about 1326, when large
sums were being spent on the decoration of the palace to fit it for
the reception of the Duke of Calabria, and Florence was beginning to
recognize the genius of the man she had exiled and vilified. Certainly
it is unlikely that Giotto, however great his friendship for Dante may
have been, would have painted the portrait of a condemned exile, as
Dante was in 1302, in a picture destined for an altar in the palace of
the chief magistrate of the city. The frescoes on the east wall of the
chapel, divided by a window, represent Paradise in three divisions. The
King standing in front of the almost entirely repainted effigy of Dante
probably represents Robert of Anjou, King of Naples, and the cardinal
on the opposite side of the window, Messer Bertrando del Poggetto; at
his feet a kneeling figure, part of whose face and head is effaced,
may be the Bishop of Florence. The figure beside Dante is supposed to
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account