"Again let me speak for you and shorten our mutual distress. First, however, I must make my own position plain. I--love your daughter, Mr. Parker." The declaration came at great cost, the speaker turned away to hide his emotion. "I think--I hope she is not indifferent to me. I would give my life to marry her and, God willing, I shall. So much for that." He swung himself about and met the eyes of first one old man, then the other. Harshly, defiantly, he added: "Understand me, nothing you can do, nothing on earth--nothing in Heaven or in hell, for that matter--will stop me from telling her about my love, when the time comes. Now then, Henry Nelson has told you that I was--that I was sent back from overseas in disgrace. You want to know if he spoke the truth. He did!" After a moment of silence Judge Halloran said, with stiff finality: "Under the circumstances there is nothing more to talk about. You amaze me when you say--" "I want to know more than if he was just telling the truth," Tom interrupted, grimly. "I want to know if you were guilty." "That was the verdict of the court martial." "To hell with that! Innocent men have been hung." A faint smile softened Gray's face. "And guilty men have gone to the gallows protesting their innocence. Which are you to believe? I made the best defense possible, but it was insufficient. I have no new evidence. I would rather endure the stigma of guilt than have you consider me a liar, and, of course, that is what you would think if I denied it." Halloran was on his feet now, and evidently anxious to terminate the interview. "There are two sides to every case, of course, and justice is not always done. However, that really makes no difference in this instance. The findings of a military tribunal are as conclusive as those of any court of law, and it is not for us to question them. To repeat what I started to say just now, I fail to understand how you can expect us to tolerate your further attentions to Miss Barbara or how you can persist in your insane determination to ask her hand in marriage." "Perhaps you'll understand when I say that I propose to clear myself." "How? When?" "Soon, I hope." "And in the meantime?" Gray considered this question briefly. "In the meantime--if you will agree to say nothing to 'Bob,' I will promise not to declare my feelings, not to see her alone." "That's a go," said the father. "Mind you, I may fail to right myself. In that event I shall feel at liberty to tell her the facts and ask her to believe in me against the world. I trust she will do so. If she loves me as I love her, she will marry me even though she knows I am a liar and a blackguard." "Never!" Halloran exploded. "'Bob' isn't that sort of a girl." "I hope it never comes to the test."