Forerunners and rivals of Christianity : $b being studies in religious history from 330 B.C. to 330 A.D., Vol. 2 (of 2)Legge, Francis
Religion
Forerunners and rivals of Christianity : $b being studies in religious history from 330 B.C. to 330 A.D., Vol. 2 (of 2)
Legge, Francis
Christianity and other religions; Religions
If these alterations of the Scriptures generally received depended on
any independent tradition, or even upon a rational criticism, they would
be of the greatest use to modern textual critics, who have in
consequence hoped eagerly that some lucky chance might yet give us a
copy of Marcion’s Gospel.[714] But the Fathers make no allusion to any
claim of the kind; and in the absence of Marcion’s own words, it seems
likely that his alterations were merely dictated by the preoccupation
regarding the Divine nature which seems with him to have amounted to a
passion. Never, he said, could the jealous and irascible God of the Jews
be identified with the loving and benevolent Spirit whom Jesus called
His Father. Hence there was not one God; but two Gods. One of these was
the Supreme Being, perfect in power as in goodness, whose name, as
perhaps the Orphics and the Ophites taught, was Love[715]. Too great to
concern Himself with sublunary things, and too pure, as Plato and Philo
had both said, to have any dealings with an impure and sinful world, He
remained seated apart in the third or highest heaven, inaccessible to
and unapproachable by man, like the unknown Father of Valentinus and the
other Gnostic sects[716]. Below Him was the Creator, or rather the
Demiurge or Fashioner of the World, in constant conflict with matter,
which he is always trying unsuccessfully to conquer and subdue in
accordance with his own limited and imperfect ideas. Just, according to
Marcion, was the Demiurge, whom he identified with the God of the Jews;
and it was this attribute of justice which prevented him from being
considered wholly evil in his nature, as was Satan, the active agent of
the matter with which the Demiurge was always striving. Yet the Demiurge
was the creator of evil on his own showing[717], and as such is entitled
to no adoration from man, whom he has brought into a world full of evil.
Man’s rescue from this is due to the Supreme God, who sent His Son Jesus
Christ on earth that He might reveal to mankind His Heavenly Father, and
thus put an end to the sway of the Demiurge.
That Jesus on His coming was seized and slain by the Jews, with at least
the connivance of the Demiurge, Marcion admitted. But as this might seem
like a defeat of the Supreme Being by His inferior, he was forced to
accept the theory called Docetism which was in favour with many other
Gnostics. According to this, the body of Jesus was not real flesh and
blood, and had indeed no actual existence, but was a phantasm which only
appeared to mankind in the likeness of a man[718]. Hence it mattered
nothing that this body, which did not really exist, appeared to suffer,
to be slain, and even to rise again. The Supreme God was not mocked, and
the resurrection of the body was to Marcion a thing unthinkable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account