Fors Clavigera (Volume 6 of 8): $b Letters to the workmen and labourers of Great BritainRuskin, John
General
Fors Clavigera (Volume 6 of 8): $b Letters to the workmen and labourers of Great Britain
Ruskin, John
Aesthetics; Conduct of life; Great Britain -- Social conditions -- 19th century; Social problems; Working class -- Great Britain
V. I must now request my reader’s attention somewhat gravely to the
questions in debate between my correspondents at Wakefield; not that
these are in themselves of any importance, but they are of extreme
importance in their general issue. In the first place, observe the
extreme difficulty of writing history. You shall have one impertinent
coxcomb after another in these days, writing constitutional Histories
of England and the like, and telling you all the relationships and all
the motives of Kings and Queens a thousand years dead; and here is
question respecting the immediate ancestor of a living lady, which does
not appear at once or easily determinable; and which I do not therefore
pursue;—here again is question respecting the connection of her husband
with the cases of bribery reported in the subjoined evidence on the
Wakefield election petition, also indeterminable;—here are farther two
or three questions respecting the treatment of his workmen, respecting
which the evidence is entirely conflicting; and finally, here is the
chapel on Wakefield bridge pulled down, [16] a model of it built in its
place, and the entire front of the historical building carried away to
decorate a private boathouse; and I, quite as knowing in architecture
as most people, am cheated into some very careful and quite useless
work, and even into many false conclusions, by the sculpture of the
sham front, decayed and broken enough in thirty years to look older
than sculpture of 500 years B.C. would, or does, in pure air.
Observe, in the second place, how petulant and eager people are, the
moment a single word touches themselves, while universal abuses may be
set before them enough to bring all the stones in heaven but what serve
for the thunder, down about their ears,—and they will go on talking
about Shakspeare and the musical glasses undisturbed, to the end of
their lives; but let a single word glance at their own windows, or
knock at their own doors, and—instantly—‘If Mr. Ruskin is what I think
him, he will retract,’ etc. etc. But, alas! Mr. Ruskin is not the least
what Mrs. Green thinks him,—does not in the smallest degree care for a
lady’s “Fie’s,” and, publishing the following letters and newspaper
extracts for the general reader’s satisfaction and E. L.’s
justification, very contentedly, for his part, ends the discussion,
though of course Fors shall be open to any further communication, if
not too long, which either Mrs. Green or her husband may desire to have
inserted.
In the following letter I have left all the passages containing due
apology, while I have removed some which contained matter of further
debate, if not offence, thereby much weakening the whole.
“Dear Mr. Ruskin,—I have been away from home, and have only recently
seen Mrs. Green’s letter in the Fors of last month.
“I am sorry to have vexed her; I did not think that you would print the
passages referring to her husband in the form in which they stood. [17]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account