In the typo description of the calcareous nodules from Michigan, Murray speaks of the _Schizothrix_ filaments at the surface of the pebbles as fairly intact, while nearer the centre only sheaths were met with. It is conceivable that in some of the tubular structures referred to _Girvanella_ we have the mineralised sheaths of a fossil Cyanophyceous genus[187]. The organic nature of these tubules has been a matter of dispute, but we may probably assume with safety that in some at least of the fossil oolitic grains there are distinct traces of some simple organism which was in all likelihood a plant. Some authors have suggested that _Girvanella_ is a calcareous alga which should be included in the family Siphoneae[188]. As a matter of fact we must be content for the present to leave its precise nature as still _sub judice_, and while regarding it as probably an alga, we may venture to consider it more fittingly discussed under the Schizophyta than elsewhere. Wethered[189] would go so far as to refer oolitic structure in general to an organic origin. While admitting that a Girvanella-like structure has been very frequently met with in oolitic rocks, it would be unwise to adopt so far-reaching a conclusion. It is at least premature to refer the formation of all oolitic structure to algal agency, and the evidence adduced is by no means convincing in every case. The discovery of _Girvanella_ and allied forms in rocks from the Cambrian[190], Ordovician, Silurian, Carboniferous, Jurassic and other systems is a striking fact, and lends support to the view that oolitic structure is in many cases intimately associated with the presence of a simple tubular organism. Among recent algae we find different genera, and representatives of different families, growing in such a manner and under such circumstances as are favourable to the formation of a ball-like mass of algal threads, which may or may not be encrusted with carbonate of lime. Similarly as regards oolitic grains of various sizes, and the occurrence in rocks of calcareous nodules, the tubular structure is not always of precisely the same type, and cannot always be included under the genus _Girvanella_. Several observers have recorded the occurrence of low forms of plant-life in the waters of thermal springs. It has been already mentioned that Cohn described the occurrence of simple plants in the warm Carlsbad Springs, and fission-plants of various types have been discovered in the thermal waters of Iceland, the Azores[191], New Zealand, the Yellowstone Park, Japan, India, and numerous other places.