Again, as among these nations the officer derives his position in the
country solely from his position in the army, and as he draws all the
distinction and the competency he enjoys from the same source, he does
not retire from his profession or is not superannuated till toward the
extreme close of life. The consequence of these two causes is that
when a democratic people goes to war after a long interval of peace
all the leading officers of the army are old men. I speak not only of
the generals, but of the non-commissioned officers, who have most of
them been stationary, or have only advanced step by step. It may be
remarked with surprise that in a democratic army after a long peace
all the soldiers are mere boys, and all the superior officers in
declining years; so that the former are wanting in experience, the
latter in vigor. This is a strong element of defeat, _for the first
condition of successful generalship is youth_. I should not have
ventured to say so if the greatest captain of modern times had not
made the observation. [The unequaled success of the aged Von Moltke in
the conduct of the Prussian war against France in 1870 is here a
curious comment on the text.]
* * * * *
I am therefore of opinion that when a democratic people engages in a
war after a long peace, it incurs much more risk of defeat than any
other nation; but it ought not easily to be cast down by its reverses,
for the chances of success for such an army are increased by the
duration of the war. When a war has at length by its long continuance
roused the whole community from their peaceful occupations and ruined
their minor undertakings the same passions which made them attach so
much importance to the maintenance of peace will be turned to arms.
War, after it has destroyed all modes of speculation, becomes itself
the great and sole speculation, to which all the ardent and ambitious
desires which equality engenders are exclusively directed. Hence it is
that the self-same democratic nations which are so reluctant to engage
in hostilities sometimes perform prodigious achievements when once
they have taken the field.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account