I wished to show what in our days a democratic people really was, and,
by a rigorously accurate picture, to produce a double effect on the
men of my day. To those who have fancied an ideal democracy, as a
brilliant and easily realized dream, I undertook to show that they had
clothed the picture in false colors; that the democratic government
which they desired, though it may procure real benefits to the people
who can bear it, has none of the elevated features with which their
imaginations would endow it; and moreover, that such a government can
only maintain itself under certain conditions of faith, enlightenment,
and private morality, which we have not yet reached, and which we must
labor to attain before grasping their political results.
To men for whom the word "democracy" is the synonym of overthrow,
spoliation, anarchy, and murder, I have endeavored to prove that it
was possible for democracy to govern society, and yet to respect
property, to recognize rights, to spare liberty, to honor religion;
that if democratic government is less fitted than other forms to
develop some of the finest faculties of the human soul, it has yet its
noble and its lovely features; and that perhaps, after all, it may be
the will of God to distribute a moderate degree of happiness to the
mass of men, and not to concentrate great felicity and great
perfection on a few. I have tried, moreover, to demonstrate that,
whatever might be their opinion upon these points, the time for
discussing them was past; that the world marched onward day by day
towards a condition of social equality, and dragged them and every one
along with it; that their only choice now lay between evils henceforth
inevitable; that the practical question of this day was not whether
you would have an aristocracy or a democracy, but whether you would
have a democratic society, without poetry and without grandeur, but
with morality and order; or a democratic society disorganized and
depraved, delivered over to a furious frenzy, or else bent beneath a
yoke heavier than any that have weighed upon mankind since the fall of
the Roman Empire.
The "Commune" in France, "Nihilism" in Russia, "Socialism" in Germany,
"Nationalism" in the United States, are all of them, each in its own
different way, remarkable historical commentaries on the prophetic
political forecast contained in the foregoing letter.
Here is ripe practical wisdom occurring in a letter written by
Tocqueville about two years before his death:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account