Elsewhere he remarks that the only feeling a soldier comes to cherish is
resignation. “He knows very well that none of his superiors will ever say
a kind word to him, and that his destiny is to pay for every annoyance
they undergo. If he behaves himself he will be compelled to toil all day
without evening recreation, and his only reward will be to be called
an idiot by his comrades, to be punished for them, and not be allowed
out oftener than they, and, in the case of a clever comrade, have his
work forced upon him—for in the regiment the clever fellows do nothing,
the fools do everything. Oh, the things I have seen! A black-hearted
sergeant, who always chose for attack weak and sickly men; a Parisian
workman, one of my comrades, on the brink of manslaughter or self-murder
from persecution, not ill-natured, but destined to be sent to Africa for
indiscipline or rebellion. Those who can’t hold their tongues or their
tempers are greatly to be pitied. I saw one strike a chief, and he was
right. I sometimes scorn myself for not having done so too. It makes
a great difference, of course, when you have a good captain or a good
lieutenant. The beginning is the hardest time in barracks. The cavalry
and artillery regiments are the worst of all. You would not believe half
the dreadful things I could tell you of them. The great evil of the army
comes from this. The corporal can injure you; that is all he can do. He
may punish, but he cannot reward. He can prevent you from going out,
but he cannot give you leave of absence before the regulated hour. But
if his power to do good is small, his power to do evil is immense. The
general cannot give a leave if the corporal opposes it. In the army the
punishment always suppresses the reward, but the reward never suppresses
the punishment; and as the number of those who can punish is at least
twenty times greater than that of those who can reward, nearly everything
that happens is disagreeable. In fact, rewards are unknown. To show a
curious example: leave of absence is not a reward; the privation of it
is a punishment. A soldier’s paradise is outside the barracks. Offer him
fifteen days of prison and after that fifteen days’ furlough, and he
will not hesitate. What the corporal and sergeant wish to avoid is being
bored, and so, to get out of work, they punish and govern by the terror
they inspire. The men do not wash their clothes because they should be
washed, but from fear the sergeant should find them dirty. The idea of
duty does not exist in the army; it is the kingdom of fear, into which no
ray of hope or justice penetrates.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account