From a Cornish Window: A New EditionQuiller-Couch, Arthur
History
From a Cornish Window: A New Edition
Quiller-Couch, Arthur
English literature -- History and criticism
"After luncheon saw the great poet Tennyson in dearest Albert's room
for nearly an hour; and most interesting it was. He is grown very
old, his eyesight much impaired. But he was very kind. Asked him to
sit down. He talked of many friends he had lost, and what it would
be if he did not feel and know that there was another world where
there would be no partings: and then he spoke with horror of the
unbelievers and philosophers who would make you believe that there
was no other world, no immortality, who tried to explain all away in
a miserable manner. We agreed that, were such a thing possible, God,
who is Love, would be far more cruel than any human being."
It was, no doubt, a touching and memorable interview--these two, aged and
great, meeting at a point of life when grandeur and genius alike feel
themselves to be lonely, daily more lonely, and exchanging beliefs upon
that unseen world where neither grandeur nor genius can plead more than
that they have used their gifts for good. And yet was not Tennyson
yielding to the old temptation to interpret the future life in terms of
this one? Speculation will not carry us far upon this road; yet, so far
as we can, let us carry clear thinking with us. Cruelty implies the
infliction of pain: and there can be no pain without feeling. What
cruelty, then, can be inflicted on the dead, if they have done with
feeling? Or what on the living, if they live in a happy delusion and pass
into nothingness without discovering the cheat? Let us hold most firmly
that there has been no cheat; but let us also be reasonable and admit
that, if cheat there be, it cannot also be cruel, since everything that
would make it a cheat would also blot out completely all chance of
discovery, and therefore all pain of discovering.
This is a question on which, beyond pleading that what little we say ought
to be (but seldom is) the result of clear thinking, I propose to say
little, not only because here is not the place for metaphysics, but
because--to quote Jowett again--"considering the 'feebleness of the human
faculties and the uncertainty of the subject,' we are inclined to believe
that the fewer our words the better. At the approach of death there is
not much said: good men are too honest to go out of the world professing
more than they know. There is perhaps no important subject about which,
at any time, even religious people speak so little to one another."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account