From an Easy ChairLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
From an Easy Chair
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history; Science
I believe that most sensible people feel as Mr. Darwin felt, and I
myself would certainly subscribe to what he wrote to me in the letter
which I have quoted above. Amongst those who feel thus strongly on
the subject there are some who can control their emotion and calmly
consider whether the pain inflicted under any given circumstances is
justifiable as leading to a great ultimate diminution of pain by the
knowledge obtained. There are others who are constitutionally incapable
of controlling their emotion in this matter. They hear dreadful stories
of cruelty, and are so upset that they are incapable of ascertaining
whether the stories are true or not. They are quite unfit to weigh the
question as to whether the pain given in the case they hear of may or
may not be a necessary step towards avoiding far greater pain in the
future for thousands of human beings and sentient animals. Far be it
from me to think harshly of these tender-hearted people, though their
mistaken outcry may tend to stop the discovery of pain-saving and
life-saving knowledge. I feel more sympathy with them than with those
(happily rare) individuals who are really indifferent to seeing or
giving bodily pain to men or to animals.
There is reason to hope that careful and well-considered statement
of the facts will eventually enable many of those who are mentally
unhinged by descriptions of pain and bloodshed to recognise that they
have been deceived, partly by their own fancies and partly by the false
statements of professional agitators. Unfortunately, there are always
present in human society individuals who find it to their advantage
to excite the minds of their more emotional fellow-citizens by tales
of horror. The lust of such power--the power to lead or urge a large
body of men driven by emotional excitement into violent action--has led
from time to time to exaggeration, misrepresentation, and elaborate
plot and perjury directed against a group of innocent or worthy people,
whose proceedings were mysterious or misunderstood by the community
at large. Thus, from time to time, the crowd has been infuriated and
led to the murder of the Jews by agitators, who started the baseless
story that the Jews had slain a Christian child, and used its blood at
their feast of the Passover. Titus Oates and Lord George Gordon made
use of the unreasoning emotion of the crowd in the same way. To a less
serious extent the emotional unreasonableness of a number of men and
women is being played upon at the present day by quite a large variety
of agitators, would-be leaders of crusades and campaigns against the
beneficent work of the physiological and medical laboratories of our
universities and medical schools.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account