Most surgeons believe that every cancer in the breast, with swelled glands, requires their extirpation. I believe that in some cases they may become cancerous, but I doubt if this happens in the greatest number. 1st. In old ulcerated cancers of the breast, they continue most often swelled during the whole of life, without suppurating. 2d. After operations, in which some deep seated ones have been left, we rarely see them become cancerous. When the cancer is reproduced, it is the wound that opens again. 3d. I have many times compared the texture of a gland of the axilla enlarged by a cancer of the breast, with that of the bronchial glands enlarged in phthisis, with that of the sub-hepatic glands swollen from steatomatous tumours, hydatids of the liver, &c. and I could discover no difference. 4th. Finally, all those who open many dead bodies may be convinced that almost all the organic diseases of the viscera which have many glands around them, are accompanied with their enlargement, whatever may be the nature of those diseases. This phenomenon struck me so much, that at one time attributed the effusions which terminate almost all these organic diseases, to the difficulty the lymph experiences in passing through these glands. But the absence of these swellings in the diseases of the heart attended with dropsy, the frequent absence of swelling of the superior extremities when the axillary glands were enlarged, the tumefaction of the lower parts, the glands of the superior being alone swelled, and many other similar proofs, which made me consider the serous effusions that take place then, as passive exhalations, analogous to those that produce hemorrhages, did not permit me to adopt this first opinion.