Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
All Dilettanti are Plagiarists. They enervate and pull to pieces all
that is original in manner or matter, and at the same time imitate,
copy, and piece out their own emptiness with it. Thus the language gets
filled with phrases and formulae stolen from all sides, which have no
longer any meaning, and you may read whole books written in a fine
_style_ and containing nothing. In a word, all that is really beautiful
and good in true poetry is profaned, rendered common, and degraded.
_In Pragmatical Poetry_
All the disadvantages of Dilettantism in Lyrical Poetry apply here in
a far higher degree. Not the art alone, but the subject also, suffers
more.
Mixing up of different kinds.
_In Histrionic Art_
Caricature of one’s own faulty individuality.
Incapacitates the mind for all occupation, through the illusion of a
fantastic mode of viewing objects.
Expense of interest and passion, without fruit.
Eternal circle of monotonous, ever repeated, ineffectual activity.
(There is nothing so attractive to Dilettanti as rehearsals.
Professional actors hate them.)
Special forbearance and pampering of theatrical Dilettanti with
applause.
Eternal stimulation towards a passionate condition and behavior,
without balance.
Feeding all hateful passions, with the worst results for civic and
domestic existence.
Blunting the feeling for poetry.
Use of exalted language for commonplace sentiments.
A rag-fair of thoughts, commonplaces, and descriptions in the memory.
Pervading affectation and mannerism, reaching also into life.
Most injurious indulgence towards the indifferent and faulty, in a
public and quite personal case.
The general tolerance for the home-made becomes in this case more
pronounced.
Most pernicious use of amateur comedies for the education of children,
where it turns into caricature. In the same manner, the most dangerous
of all amusements for universities, &c.
Destruction of the ideality of art, because the Dilettante, not being
able to raise himself through the appropriation of artistic ideas and
traditions, must do all through a pathological reality.
THE THEORY OF LITERATURE
THE PRODUCTION OF A NATIONAL CLASSIC[5]
(_Literarischer Sansculottismus_)
(1795)
Those who consider it an absolute duty to connect definite concepts
with the words which they employ in speaking and writing will very
rarely use the expressions, “classical author” and “classical work.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account