Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 4, October 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 4, October 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Mr. Buckingham opens with a sweeping condemnation of all former writers
on America, and then adroitly insinuates that his work is the “_ne plus
ultra_” of all works. No one who heard him lecture can doubt his egotism
or vanity. We were not, therefore, much surprised at this exordium. The
text, however, keeps up the farce, and whether describing the emoluments
of the bar, the genius and productions of our poets, the statistics of
the States or Union, the conduct of political parties, or the advance of
taste, morals, or religion, he is sure to drag in something respecting
himself, and to misrepresent, more or less, the subject under
discussion. Did the book merit the time and space, we would quote some
of its remarks to shew what an arrant block-head, or else what a wilful
libeller, this J. Silk Buckingham is.
This want of truth in Mr. Buckingham is unpardonable. While here, he was
feasted, huzzaed, followed by crowds, in short made a lion of,—and, as
he himself says, he had every opportunity to gain correct information.
But he seems to have slighted them all. His exaggerations out-romance
Amadis de Gaul. He is beside painfully dull, prosing away, page after
page, just as he used to dilute his twaddle, when retailing it, by the
hour, at a shilling a head. His work scarcely lays claim to mediocrity.
Although ushered in by a flourish of trumpets from presses on both sides
of the Atlantic, and attended by a pompous dedication to His Royal
Highness Prince Albert, the volumes are inferior in every respect to the
unpretending work, on this country, lately published by Mr. Combe. As
Brougham said of Sheridan’s statesmanship, “it is neither a bad book,
nor a good book, nor an indifferent book—the fact is, it is no book at
all.”
* * * * *
_Lectures on the History of Literature, Ancient and Modern: from
the German of Frederick Schlegel: 1 vol. J. and H. G. Langley:
New York, 1841._
This work is already extensively known, through the medium of foreign
editions; but the present imprint of it will be none the less welcome on
that account. We rejoice to see our publishers begin to make head
against the reprint of worthless novels, by issuing, instead of such
trash, works of a standard character like this. Let the press second
them in so noble an effort.
The object of Schlegel, in this volume, has been to give a general view
of the development and spirit of literature, and to show its influence
on the character of successive ages, from ancient to modern times. We
cannot appreciate, and cannot therefore be expected to praise, the
German fondness for reducing everything to a theory, and we must
consequently protest against the attempt made by our author to give his
subject such a character. Nevertheless the book is full of profound
reflections, and displays great research. It is the result of a full
mind, and not the idle rhapsody of a visionary.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account