Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 5, November 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 5, November 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
_History of the War in the Peninsula, and in the South of
France, from the year 1807 to the year 1814. By_ W. F. Napier,
C. B., Colonel, _&c. From the Fourth Edition. Complete in Four
Volumes. With Numerous Engravings. Carey and Hart:
Philadelphia._
Colonel Napier’s “History of the Peninsula War” is a work whose general
features are sufficiently well understood. In the thoroughness of its
survey and in the minute and exact particularity of its details, if not
in more important and comprehensive regards, it is equalled certainly by
no other book on the subject discussed, and perhaps by few histories of
any kind. The author’s extensive political acquaintance with the events
agitating all Europe at the period investigated, and especially the part
he bore in some of these events, with his obvious enthusiasm for
military affairs, rendered him as fitting for the task which he has
undertaken as any individual of his age. It may be said, indeed, and not
altogether paradoxically, that he was somewhat _too_ well qualified for
this task. The agitating incidents _quorum pars magna fuit_ have so
forcibly impressed his imagination as to mislead his understanding in
respect to the _relative_ importance of these incidents. He discourses
of the “Peninsular Campaign” (pretty much, by the way, as all Englishmen
discourse of it) as if _it alone_ were the proper subject of all human
deliberation. No one will be willing to deny the interest which
appertains to it, nor the magnitude of the results to which it led. We
mean to say, however, that, except to Colonel Napier and the Duke of
Wellington, it is not the only important topic in the universe.
Hitherto the American reader of history has been able to procure this
work only from our public libraries, and the enterprize of Messieurs
Carey and Hart in placing it within reach, is worthy of all
commendation. They must have been at unusual expense in this
undertaking. The volumes are thick octavos, and are illustrated by no
less than fifty-five lithographed plans, (which, by the way, are not
very well executed.) At the same time these publishers can scarcely
expect remuneration from a very extensive sale. By public institutions
and military men the work will be valued and purchased. But beyond
these, with few exceptions, the public will content itself with the
means already in its power of referring to the history in our libraries.
The gentlemen in question are, of course, the best judges of their own
affairs; but it does seem to us that they have erred in permitting the
_foreign_ value and reputation of the work to influence them in making
an American reprint.
* * * * *
_Ten Thousand a Year. By the Author of The Diary of a London
Physician. Carey and Hart: Philadelphia._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account