Graham's Magazine, Vol. XLI, No. 5, November 1852Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XLI, No. 5, November 1852
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Mr. Bryant’s oration is the ideal of what such an oration should be, a
model of appreciative criticism--fine style, and just laudation of high
qualities, and worthy contribution to the land’s literature. We rejoice
to learn that Messrs. Stringer & Townsend propose shortly to bring out a
splendid complete edition of his works, finely illustrated by Darley,
like Putnam’s edition of Irving, and prophecy equal success to their
enterprise.
* * * * *
_The Master Builder: or a Life at a Trade. By Day Kellog Lee.
Author of “Summerfield, or Life on a Farm.” Redfield, Clinton
Hall, New York._
This is a simple, domestic tale, founded on the difficulties, the
struggles, and the ultimate success of a poor foundling boy, thrown in
his infancy among strangers, and fighting his way, through the great
battle-field of life, in spite of all difficulties, by dint of genius,
backed by industry, perseverance, energy, honesty, and faith, to
happiness, fame, and fortune.
The subject is well conceived, the plot well planned, the characters, in
the main, well drawn, though in some sort exaggerated, and the tale, as
regards matter, well told.
It would be pleasant to end here; but we should do justice neither to
the author nor to ourselves, did we not speak the truth, right out. And
the truth is--that all these excellences, and the book itself, are
almost _in toto_ ruined by the detestable affectation, false sentiment,
and sickening transcendentalism of the manner.
Young ladies of an æsthetic turn of mind, members of a sentimental
clique in some small western town, may think such passages as the
following _sweetly pretty_: “She lived opulently in a lofty
book;”--monstrous poor lodgings for opulence, it seems to us--“she was
industrious; and yet she lived all she could in the woods, and loved to
lie down in the hay-fields, or under the oaks on the hill pasture
overlooking the village, and warble responses to the birds, and let them
sing her at last to sleep. She loved to feed the fishes in
meadow-brooks. She built nests for robins and sparrows every spring.”
But the author may rely on it, that men of judgment and sense, and women
of matured taste, will, according to their natures, laugh at or lament
such perversity.
For the writer can write better, but chooses to write worse. Some of his
descriptions of scenery are simple, terse, and beautiful--some of his
glimpses at character true, shrewd, and striking--though his style is,
at times, provincial, inelegant, and ungrammatical; as when he writes
that some person “like to have done so and so”--meaning that he “was on
the point of doing so;” or that a boy’s nostrils “palpitated the spirit
of a man,” which is neither grammar nor sense, much less English.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account