Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 2, February 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 2, February 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
But, if Mrs. Norton is less correct than Mrs. Hemans, she is, on the
other hand, more nervous, more passionate, and at times more lofty. No
one can read “The Dream” without being struck by the truth of the
remark, that Mrs. Norton is the Byron of our female poets. There are
passages in some of her poems of greater power than any passages of like
length in Mrs. Hemans’ writings, though at the same time, there are a
far greater number of inferior lines in the poetry of Mrs. Norton, than
in that of her gifted sister. In short, the one is the more equal, the
other is the more daring. One is the more skilful writer: the other
shows glimpses of a bolder genius. There is less prettiness, and not so
much sameness in Mrs. Norton as in Mrs. Hemans. The former is not yet,
perhaps, the equal of the latter, but she possesses the power to be so,
if her rich fancy and deep feeling, now scarcely known to herself,
should ever be brought so completely under her control as were the
talents of Mrs. Hemans.
If Mrs. Norton had written nothing before, this volume would have
established her claim to be the first of living poetesses; but who that
is familiar with the world of song can forget the many gems—rich, and
beautiful, and rare—with which she has spangled beforetime her starry
crown? The world has taken more care of her glory than she has herself,
and the random pieces she has poured forth so divinely at intervals, and
which hitherto she has made no effort to preserve, have found their way
into the hearts of all who can be touched by the mournful or the
beautiful, until her name is cherished alike in the humble cottage and
the princely hall. And now she has come forth in more stately guise, not
as a new author among strangers, but as one long tried and known, one
endeared to us by old association, one whose melancholy music is, as it
were, a part of our very being.
“The Dream” is the longest poem in the volume before us, but, as it
makes no pretension to be considered a story, and has really no plot, we
shall not judge it by the ordinary rule of criticism. We shall consider
it only as a string of pearls, loosely joined together by the simplest
contrivance, the idea of a dream, narrated by a daughter to her
mother,—and, judging it in this way, we give it unqualified praise.
That its merit is unequal, is, in our eyes, no objection to its
beauty,—for have not all poets skimmed the ground as well as soared to
heaven? Yes! “The Dream” is unequal, but so is Lallah Rookh, so is
Marmion, so are all the tales of Byron, and so—to ascend a step
higher—is Comus, or Hamlet, or even the Iliad.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account