Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 5, May 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 5, May 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
In truth, the great feature of the “Curiosity Shop” is its chaste,
vigorous, and glorious _imagination_. This is the one charm, all potent,
which alone would suffice to compensate for a world more of error than
Mr. Dickens ever committed. It is not only seen in the conception, and
general handling of the story, or in the invention of character; but it
pervades every sentence of the book. We recognise its prodigious
influence in every inspired word. It is this which induces the reader
who is at all ideal, to pause frequently, to re-read the occasionally
quaint phrases, to muse in uncontrollable delight over thoughts which,
while he wonders he has never hit upon them before, he yet admits that
he never has encountered. In fact it is the wand of the enchanter.
Had we room to particularise, we would mention as points evincing most
distinctly the ideality of the “Curiosity Shop”—the picture of the shop
itself—the newly-born desire of the worldly old man for the peace of
green fields—his whole character and conduct, in short—the
school-master, with his desolate fortunes, seeking affection in little
children—the haunts of Quilp among the wharf-rats—the tinkering of the
Punch-men among the tombs—the glorious scene where the man of the forge
sits poring, at deep midnight, into that dread fire—again the whole
conception of this character; and, last and greatest, the stealthy
approach of Nell to her death—her gradual sinking away on the journey
to the village, so skilfully indicated rather than described—her
pensive and prescient meditation—the fit of strange musing which came
over her when the house _in which she was to die_ first broke upon her
sight—the description of this house, of the old church, and of the
churchyard—every thing in rigid consonance with the one impression to
be conveyed—that deep meaningless well—the comments of the Sexton upon
death, and upon his own secure life—this whole world of mournful yet
peaceful idea merging, at length, into the decease of the child Nelly,
and the uncomprehending despair of the grandfather. These concluding
scenes are so drawn that human language, urged by human thought, could
go no farther in the excitement of human feelings. And the pathos is of
that best order which is relieved, in great measure, by ideality. Here
the book has never been equalled,—never approached except in one
instance, and that is in the case of the “Undine” of De La Motte Fouqué.
The imagination is perhaps as great in this latter work, but the pathos,
although truly beautiful and deep, fails of much of its effect through
the material from which it is wrought. The chief character, being
endowed with purely fanciful attributes, cannot command our full
sympathies, as can a simple denizen of earth. In saying, a page or so
above, that the death of the child left too painful an impression, and
should therefore have been avoided, we must, of course, be understood as
referring to the work as a whole, and in respect to its general
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account