Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 6, June 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 6, June 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
The characters, however, are still more common-place. De Rohan and
Isabel are like all James’ lovers, mere nothings—Father Welland and
Corse de Leon are the beneficent spirits, and Meyrand and Masseran are
the evil geniuses, of the novel. The other characters are lifeless,
common, and uncharacteristic. They make no impression, and you almost
forget their names. There is no originality in any of them, and save a
passage of fine writing here and there, nothing to be praised in the
book. Corse de Leon, the principal character, talks philosophy like
Bulwer’s heroes, and is altogether a plagiarism from that bombastic,
unnatural, cut-throat school,—besides, he possesses a universality of
knowledge, combined with a commensurable power, which, although they get
the hero very conveniently out of scrapes, belie all nature. In short,
this is but a readable novel, and a mere repetition of the author’s
former works.
* * * * *
_“Insubordination; An American Story of Real Life.” By the
Author of the “Subordinate.” One Volume. Baltimore; Knight &
Colman._
The author of the “Subordinate” is Mr. T. S. Arthur, of Baltimore,
formerly one of the editors of the “Visiter and Athenæum,” and now, we
believe, connected with “The Budget,” a new monthly journal of that
city—with the literature of which, generally, he has been more or less
identified for many years past.
“The Subordinate” we have not had the pleasure of reading. The present
book, “Insubordination,” is excellently written in its way; although we
must be pardoned for saying that the _way_ itself is not of a high order
of excellence. It is all well enough to justify works of this class by
hyper-democratic allusions to the “moral dignity” of low life, &c.
&c.—but we cannot understand why a gentleman should feel or affect a
_penchant_ for vulgarity; nor can we comprehend the “moral dignity” of a
dissertation upon bed-bugs: for the opening part of “Insubordination”
is, if anything, a treatise on these peculiar animalculæ.
Some portions of the book are worthy of the author’s ability, which it
would rejoice us to see more profitably occupied. For example, a passage
where Jimmy, an ill-treated orphan, relates to the only friend he has
ever found, some of the poignant sorrows of his childhood, embodies a
fine theme, handled in a manner which has seldom been excelled. Its
pathos is exquisite. The morality of the story is no doubt good; but the
reasoning by which it is urged is decrepid, and far too pertinaciously
thrust into the reader’s face at every page. The mode in which all the
characters are _reformed_, one after the other, belongs rather to the
desirable than to the credible. The style of the narrative is easy and
_truthful_. We dare say the work will prove popular in a certain sense;
but, upon the whole, we do not like it.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account