Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 3, September 1842Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 3, September 1842
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
These are charming volumes, written with a freshness and spirit that
delights and would surprise us were we not familiar with the first work
of their author. Mrs. Kirkland has opened a new vein in our national
literature. Her sketches of forest scenery and wood-craft, with all its
varied details, are not less true than graphic. We Americans are
probably inclined to think too lightly of the vigor and intelligence
displayed in them; that bad old adage about the estimate of a prophet in
his native land unfortunately applies with force to Mrs. Kirkland, Mrs.
Brooks and some other writers of this country whose works, while they
excite comparatively little attention here, are passing through numerous
editions abroad. All the world has read the pleasant stories in “Our
Village,” by Miss Mitford. We institute no comparison between her and
our own “Mary Clavers,” but we think our countrywoman has exhibited
powers infinitely superior to those of the popular delineator of English
rural life. She is sometimes _extravagant_, indeed; but a tendency to
extravagance has its foundation in nature, and is necessary in all works
of art, from pen or pencil, to produce a true impression. Having made a
pedestrian tour through the country about “Montecute,” a few years ago,
and gained by observation some knowledge of its inhabitants, we thought
after glancing at a few of Mrs. Kirkland’s chapters that she had
exaggerated too much their peculiarities; but on closing her volumes we
are as confident of their truth as of their extreme cleverness. One or
two of Miss Mitford’s stories may be read with pleasure, and a
philosopher can endure a third; but the fourth invariably induces sleep
or weariness. There is, however, no monotony to pall in “Mary Clavers;”
the tragic and the comic, the pathetic and the droll, succeed each other
so rapidly in her works that they are as various in their tone as the
inimitable “Don Juan.”
We might find some faults in “Forest Life,” but its good qualities so
predominate that the task becomes both difficult and ungracious. We will
allude to one only—the too frequent introduction of French words and
phrases—not, certainly, from vanity, for no woman has less affectation
than our author—but doubtless from habit and a desire of condensation.
A pithy French phrase of three words, _to those who understand the
language_, will frequently convey more meaning than half a dozen English
lines; but, Mrs. Clavers, there are in this world a vast number of very
decent people who know as little of French as a politician does of
honesty.
* * * * *
_The American in Egypt, with Rambles through Arabia Petræa and
the Holy Land, during the Years 1839 and 1840. By James Ewing
Cooley. Illustrated with numerous Steel Engravings, and Etchings
by D. C. Johnston. One vol. 8vo., pp. 610. New York, D. Appleton
& Co., 1842._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account