Graham's Magazine Vol XXXII. No. 3. March 1848Various
General
Graham's Magazine Vol XXXII. No. 3. March 1848
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
One of the happiest examples, in a small way, of the
carrying-one's-self-in-a-hand-basket logic, is to be found in a London
weekly paper called "The Popular Record of Modern Science; a Journal
of Philosophy and General Information." This work has a vast
circulation, and is respected by eminent men. Sometime in November,
1845, it copied from the "Columbian Magazine" of New York, a rather
adventurous article of mine, called "Mesmeric Revelation." It had the
impudence, also, to spoil the title by improving it to "The Last
Conversation of a Somnambule"--a phrase that is nothing at all to the
purpose, since the person who "converses" is _not_ a somnambule. He is
a sleep-waker--_not_ a sleep-walker; but I presume that "The Record"
thought it was only the difference of an _l_. What I chiefly complain
of, however, is that the London editor prefaced my paper with these
words:--"The following is an article communicated to the Columbian
Magazine, a journal of respectability and influence in the United
States, by Mr. Edgar A. Poe. _It bears internal evidence of
authenticity._"!
There is no subject under heaven about which funnier ideas are, in
general, entertained than about this subject of internal evidence. It
is by "internal evidence," observe, that we decide upon the mind.
But to "The Record:"--On the issue of my "Valdemar Case," this journal
copies it, as a matter of course, and (also as a matter of course)
improves the title, as in the previous instance. But the editorial
comments may as well be called profound. Here they are:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account