came of age and began to frequent the palaestra, devoted himself to such
exercises as produced activity rather than great strength, considering
that the latter was of little use for war. So he exercised himself in
running, and in wrestling “only so far as he could stand on his feet,”
but he spent most of his time in the practice of arms.[154] Equally
unsuitable for war was the habit of life produced by athletic training.
“The athlete’s nature,” says Plato, “is sleepy, and the least variation
from his routine is liable to cause him serious illness.”[155] Such a
man is incapable of standing the various vicissitudes of a campaign, and
therefore we find athletics condemned not only by philosophers like
Plato and Aristotle but by generals such as Epaminondas, Alexander, and
Philopoemen.[156] “The athlete,” says Euripides, “is the slave of his
jaw and of his belly.”
Medical science confirmed the verdict of the philosopher and the
soldier. Hippocrates of Cos, “the father of medicine,” and a
contemporary of Herodicus and Gorgias, condemned the high state of
training produced by athletics as a dangerous and unstable condition of
body.[157] To live in a constant state of training is bad for any man,
and especially under a system so unscientific as that of the Greeks.
There was another reason for the condemnation of athletics by military
authorities. The old Homeric sports had been practical and military: the
system of physical education which had grown out of them had produced
that all-round development which made a man fit for all the duties of
life in peace or war; but the new specialized education produced only a
one-sided development, and at the same time was so exacting as to leave
no time for the practice of military exercises. Plato was an ardent
advocate of physical training. Trained by his father Ariston, who was a
distinguished athlete, he had won victories in wrestling at Delphi,
Nemea, and the Isthmus, and is even stated, though with less
probability, to have won the Olympic crown. But the philosopher could
find no place for the athletics of his day in his ideal state, and he
therefore, in the _Laws_,[158] proposes a new and more practical
gymnastic based on the requirements of war. From the age of six, boys,
and girls too, are to learn to ride, to learn the use of the bow, the
javelin, and the sling, and to learn to use the left hand as well as the
right. In wrestling and boxing all tricks invented “out of a vain spirit
of competition” are to be eschewed and only such forms practised as are
likely to be of service for war. The dances, too, must be military in
character, marches and processions in armour and on horseback, or mimic
contests like the dances of Crete and Sparta. In another passage[159] he
describes the competitions suitable for his ideal state. All foot-races
are to be run in armour, there is to be a long-distance race of sixty
stades in heavy armour, and a still longer race of 100 stades over
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account