The growing popularity of athletics and the excessive honours showered
upon physical excellence could hardly escape criticism. In that age of
intense intellectual activity there must have been many far-sighted
observers who resented the predominance of athletics, though perhaps
they feared to express their feelings. One at least there was who knew
no such fear, and fortunately his protest has survived. The bold and
original thinker, Xenophanes of Colophon, was exactly contemporary with
the movement which we have been describing. Born at Colophon about the
year 576 B.C. he was forced to leave his native place at the age of
twenty-five, and for sixty-five years travelled about the cities of
Greece and Sicily, finally settling at Elea in Italy, where he became
the founder of the Eleatic school of philosophy, and died in the year
480 B.C. A fearless critic of the current ideas about the gods, denying
that the godhead could be like unto man, he may well have been
scandalized at the representation of gods and heroes as athletes, and at
the offering of divine honours to victors in the games; and his wide
experience of men and cities showed him clearly the danger of the
growing worship of athletics. After enumerating the honours shown to the
athlete he continues: “Yet is he not so worthy as I, and my wisdom is
better than the strength of men and horses. Nay, this is a foolish
custom, nor is it right to honour strength more than excellent wisdom.
Not though there were among the people a man good at boxing, or in the
pentathlon, or in wrestling, nay, nor one with swiftness of foot which
is most honoured in all contests of human strength—not for his presence
would the city be better governed. And small joy would there be for a
city should one in contests win a victory by the banks of Pisa. These
things do not make fat the dark corners of the city.”
Less than a century later the words of Xenophanes are echoed by
Euripides, but the object of the protest is no longer the same. The
class of professional athletes whom Euripides denounces did not exist in
the days of the older poet. It is against the excessive importance
attached to athletics, the false and one-sided ideal, that Xenophanes
protests. In his wanderings through the cities of Greece he has learnt
by bitter experience the evils that exist, evils of tyranny and party
strife, extremes of luxury and poverty, and he feels that the energies
of his countrymen are being misdirected. It is not a little curious that
foreign writers, deceived by the glamour of Olympia, are wont to treat
the protest of Xenophanes as the captious utterance of a soured and
peevish cynic. Yet the fragments of his writings which exist show him to
have been a man of wide experience and sympathies; and in England, where
we have witnessed a similar wave of athleticism, his wisdom is generally
recognized. Let us pause to consider what was the state of athletics in
the time of Xenophanes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account