Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Mythology, Greek, in literature
There is no doubt (i) that the _Helen_ is not serious either in intention
or execution; (ii) that there is good evidence for supposing a connexion
between the play and the festival of the Mother and the Maid, the
Thesmophoria; (iii) that Aristophanes’ jokes about Proteus-Proteas and
the rest do support the view that Euripides has in his mind the history
of a family who have nothing to do with Menelaus and Helen; (iv) that in
the play there are points, such as “Eido” (the baby-name of Theonoe),
which are irrelevant to the story. Are we, then, to accept Verrall’s
account? The sound view would appear to be that Euripides offered to
the Archon a work which for once was a burlesque. So sincere a thinker
as Euripides was certain sooner or later to attack himself, at any rate
to examine his position and methods with humorous detachment. So far we
may, we must, go with Verrall; the elaborate and delightfully detailed
development we can hardly accept—the evidence is not sufficiently strong.
But the poet is making fun not only of himself. The false Helen and her
disappearance at a crisis in the action, are not merely miracles of a
type in which he utterly disbelieves; they are features which even a
believer would remove as far as possible into the background. In handling
this fairy-tale with such _naïveté_, he is possibly laughing at some
indiscreet fellow-dramatist;[672] certainly he is ridiculing the popular
belief in such legends. Helen herself cannot credit the tale of Leda
and the Swan.[673] When given the choice between two accounts of her
brothers’ fate, she prefers the non-miraculous version.[674] Even the
dramatist’s own dislike of soothsayers is elaborately expounded by the
Greek messenger and sympathetically echoed by the chorus,[675] absurdly
enough in a play which contains Theonoe, whom the chorus themselves have
induced Helen to consult, and with success; although of course Theonoe
knows only what could be learned by listening to the talk of Menelaus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account