H.M.I.: Some Passages in the Life of One of H.M. Inspectors of SchoolsSneyd-Kynnersley, E. M. (Edmund McKenzie)
History
H.M.I.: Some Passages in the Life of One of H.M. Inspectors of Schools
Sneyd-Kynnersley, E. M. (Edmund McKenzie)
Education -- Great Britain; School management and organization -- Great Britain
The ordinary inspector soon acquired the habit of framing his
endorsement on the general principles of his craft. It was not thought
fair to speak ill of a teacher on his certificate, unless there were
special grounds. Therefore one proceeded by judicious omission. If one
read that Mr. A. “taught the elementary subjects with fair success” one
drew two inferences; (1) that he could _not_ teach anything else; (2)
that his discipline was weak, because it was not mentioned. But if it
was stated that Mrs. B. “maintained good order, and was particularly
successful in teaching handwriting,” it became obvious that her
arithmetic was a deplorable failure. So that to the trained eye the
_suppressio veri_ was not a _suggestio falsi_.
But useful as the system was, it was open to two strong objections.
Firstly, it was often hard on a teacher, for the inspector might
err, and the endorsement was permanent. Secondly, and this was the
last straw, it became an intolerable nuisance to the inspector. In a
school of 100 children it was easy to be terse, innocuous, and fairly
truthful. But I open a recent notebook, and find a school of 600 boys
with 21 teachers. Supposing that ten of these teachers want certificate
reports; conceive the strain on the imagination, or the commonplace
book! Therefore a cynical and eccentric colleague adopted the startling
method of applying the same treatment to all. If this school of 600
boys passed a good examination on the whole, but had two weak classes
out of the twenty, then the correct summary would be--“The school has
on the whole passed a good examination. Standards II.(b) and III.(c)
are not equal to the rest.” _And he wrote this on the certificates of
all the ten men._ Eight at least would say, “What have I to do with the
two black sheep? Mine are white.” But the inspector replied, like Mrs.
Prig, “Who do you think’s to wash one feater, and miss another, and
wear out one’s eyes with all manner of fine work of that description,
for half-a-crown a day?” Or words to that effect.
It was recorded of another inspector, whose massive intellect had
partly given way under the strain of compiling reports, that in a
certain school he wrote:
“The master’s wife has lately died: the school has been painted
pea-green.
“J. Tearem, H.M.I.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account