When Volger, not a bad opponent at the bottom, and Haeckel had made
their speeches, indicating at once certain lasting antitheses within the
subtle philosophy of Darwinism, Virchow closes the debates and the
Congress with a most dangerous blessing. In essentials he is once more
on the side of Haeckel. He suggests that geology should be allowed to
mature a little before final judgment is passed. The strongest evidence
for evolution is found in embryology (the science of the embryonic forms
and uterine development of living species of animals). The prophecy was
fulfilled, if ever prophecy was, and in Haeckel’s own most particular
field of work. But, in fine—he returns to his point—the main thing is
the “pursuit of truth.” And since “the most earnest ecclesiastical
teachers” declared that “God is truth,” he could not do better than
close with a reminder (I quote him _verbatim_) of “the compromise that
may be effected between science and the Church.” Translated into plain
language, that means: My dear children, fight it out as you will, but
respect the Church always as the main thing, and you will do well,
however much you differ. Thus closed this remarkable Scientific
Congress—as quietly as a bomb that smokes noiselessly, like a whiff from
a tobacco pipe. But one day it will burst.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CHAPTER VI
THE “GENERAL MORPHOLOGY”
The speech at the Scientific Congress in 1863 was the first open
confession that Haeckel felt bound to make. But the real work for the
new ideas began on his return to Jena. Nothing was further from
Haeckel’s thoughts at that time than the idea of becoming merely the
populariser of Darwinism in Germany. He has often been spoken of since
in lay circles as such. It is entirely wrong. He had the courage to
recognise his debt whenever he contracted one; and certainly Darwin
supplied the groundwork of his colour-scheme. But he was much too
independent and individual in his nature not to take the axe in his own
hand at once and begin to hew away himself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account