Half Hours With Modern Scientists: Lectures and EssaysTyndall, John
Philosophy
Half Hours With Modern Scientists: Lectures and Essays
Tyndall, John
Science
It is precisely in conditions, however, that Mr. Darwin claims a
solution of this problem. Conditions concern all that relates to air,
heat, light, land, water, and whatever they imply. Our second objection,
consequently, is, that conditions are quite inadequate to account for
present organized differences, from a single cell. Geological time, for
example, falls short, after all, of infinite time; or, in known
geological eras, let us calculate them as liberally as we may, there is
not time enough to account for the presently-existing varieties, from
one, or even several, primordial forms. So to speak, it is not _in_
geological time to account for the transformation of the elephant into
the stag from acceleration, or for that of the stag into the elephant
from retardation, of movement. And we may speak similarly of the growth
of the neck of the giraffe, or even of the elevation of the monkey into
man. Moreover, time apart, conditions have no such power in themselves.
It is impossible to conceive of animal or vegetable effluvia ever
creating the nerve by which they are felt, and so gradually the
Schneiderian membrane, nose, and whole olfactory apparatus. Yet these
effluvia are the conditions of smell, and, _ex hypothesi_, ought to have
created it. Did light, or did the pulsations of the air, ever by any
length of time, indent into the sensitive cell, eyes, and a pair of
eyes—ears, and a pair of ears? Light conceivably might shine for ever
without such a wonderfully complicated result as an eye. Similarly, for
delicacy and marvellous ingenuity of structure, the ear is scarcely
inferior to the eye; and surely it is possible to think of a whole
infinitude of those fitful and fortuitous air-tremblings, which we call
sound, without indentation into anything whatever of such an organ.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account