Hans Holbein the Younger, Volume 2 (of 2)Chamberlain, Arthur B. (Arthur Bensley)
History
Hans Holbein the Younger, Volume 2 (of 2)
Chamberlain, Arthur B. (Arthur Bensley)
Holbein, Hans, 1497-1543 -- Criticism and interpretation; Painters -- Germany -- Biography
It has been generally supposed that on the death of Prince Henry, two
years after they were presented to him, the pictures passed into the
possession of Charles I; and as they were not included among the
pictures of that King’s collection sold by order of the Commonwealth in
1648-53, Dr. Lappenberg concluded that they must have remained at
Whitehall until destroyed in the fire at that palace in 1698. Further
evidence, however, appears to contradict this conclusion. In Van der
Doort’s carefully-prepared catalogue of Charles I’s collection, although
several less important works by Holbein are included, among them two
miniatures, these two celebrated pictures are not mentioned. Again,
Sandrart, in his autobiography, describes the two compositions in some
detail, after seeing them in 1627 in the Earl of Arundel’s possession,
in the long garden gallery in Arundel House. He does not say whether
they were pictures or drawings, so that they may have been only the
original designs; it is much more probable, however, that they were the
large paintings, as Sandrart speaks of them first of all, as the chief
of Holbein’s works belonging to the Earl, and afterwards describes three
of his best known portraits, hanging in the same gallery, those of
Erasmus, Sir Thomas More, and a “Princess of Lorraine” (the Duchess of
Milan), which seems to indicate that Lord Arundel possessed the large
works. It has been suggested that they may have been presented by
Charles I to the Earl; but it is more likely that they were obtained by
exchange with that monarch. Later on they were taken abroad with the
rest of the collection by the Countess of Arundel, and were in Amsterdam
at the time of her death in 1654. In the inventory then drawn up they
are merely described as “Triumpho della Richezza” and “Triumpho della
Poverta.” Probably they were among the pictures hastily sold by Lord
Stafford in that town immediately after his mother’s decease.[52] The
last trace of their history to be found is in a paragraph in Félibien’s
_Entretiens sur les Vies et sur les Ouvrages des plus excellents
Peintres anciens et modernes_, published in 1666, in which he speaks of
them as having been brought from Flanders to Paris: “Il y avait encore
dans la maison des Ostrelins, dans la salle du Convive, deux tableaux à
détrempe, qu’on a veûs icy depuis quelques années, et qu’on avait
envoyez de Flandres.”[53]
Footnote 52:
See _Burlington Magazine_, August 1911, vol. xix. pp. 282-6.
Footnote 53:
Quoted by Woltmann, i. p. 382.
If Félibien is correct, the pictures had once more come into the
possession of the Hanseatic League. They were, no doubt, purchased in
Amsterdam by that body, and forwarded to Paris. No further record of
them has been discovered, and as they were already in a damaged state
when presented to the Prince of Wales, the probability is that they have
perished.
[Illustration:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account