Harper's New Monthly Magazine, No. XXVII, August 1852, Vol. VVarious
History
Harper's New Monthly Magazine, No. XXVII, August 1852, Vol. V
Various
American literature -- Periodicals; Civilization -- Periodicals; Culture -- Periodicals
In comparing the two as artists, we shall not venture an opinion;
but we must confess to a strong liking for such specimen of
humanity, as makes its humanity shine through whatever art it
embraces. Such humanity sliding into song, slides through the song,
and makes the song an echo; such humanity reveling in painting,
makes the painting only a shadow on the wall. Every true artist
should be greater than his art; or else it is the art that makes
him great.
And while we are upon this matter of song, we take the liberty of
suggesting, in behalf of plain-spoken, and simple-minded people,
that musical criticism is nowadays arraying itself in a great
brocade of words, of which the fustian only is clear to common
readers. We can readily understand that the art of music, like other
arts, should have its technicalities of expression; but we can not
understand with what propriety those technicalities should be warped
into such notices, as are written professedly for popular
entertainment and instruction.
If, Messrs. Journalists, your musical critiques are intended solely
for the eye of connoisseurs, stick to your shady Italian; but if
they be intended for the enlightenment of such hungry outside
readers, as want to know, in plain English, how such or such a
concert went off, and in what peculiar way each artist excels, for
Heaven's sake, give us a taste again of old fashioned Saxon
expletive! He seems to us by far the greatest critic, who can carry
to the public mind the clearest and the most accurate idea of what
was sung, and of the way in which it was sung. It would seem,
however, that we are greatly mistaken; and that the palm of
excellence should lie with those, whose periods smack most
of the green-room, and cover up opinions with a profusion of
technicalities. We shall not linger here, however, lest we be
attacked in language we can not understand.
* * * * *
Among the novelties which have provoked their share of the boudoir
chit-chat, and which go to make our monthly digest of trifles
complete, may be reckoned the appearance of a company of trained
animals at the Astor Place Opera House. Their débût was modest and
maidenly; and could hardly have made an eddy in the talk, had not
the purveyors of that classic temple, entered an early protest
against the performance, as derogatory to the dignity of the place.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account