Harper's New Monthly Magazine, Vol. 1. No 1, June 1850Various
General
Harper's New Monthly Magazine, Vol. 1. No 1, June 1850
Various
American literature -- Periodicals; Civilization -- Periodicals; Culture -- Periodicals
We have no desire to pursue this view of George Sand's writings to its
ultimate consequences. It is enough for our present purpose to indicate
the source and nature of the influence she exercises. Taking her life
and her works together, their action and re-action upon each other, it
may be observed that such a writer could be produced and fostered only
in such a state of society as that of Paris. With all her genius she
would perish in London. The moral atmosphere of France is necessary
alike to its culture and reception--the volcanic soil--the perpetual
excitement--the instability of the people and the government--the
eternal turmoil, caprice, and transition--a society agitated and
polluted to its core. These elements of fanaticism and confusion, to
which she has administered so skillfully, have made her what she is. In
such a country as England, calm, orderly, and conservative, her social
philosophy would lack earth for its roots and air for its blossoms. The
very institutions of France, upon which no man can count for an hour,
are essential to her existence as a writer.
But time that mellows all things has not been idle with George Sand.
After having written "Indiana," "Lelie," "Valentine," and sundry other
of her most conspicuous works, she found it necessary to defend herself
against the charge of advocating conjugal infidelity. The defense, to be
sure, was pre-eminently sophistical, and rested on a complete evasion of
the real question; but it was a concession to the feelings and decorum
of society which could not fail in some measure to operate as a
restraint in future labors. Her subsequent works were not quite so
decisive on these topics; and in some of them marriage was even treated
with a respectful recognition, and love was suffered to run its course
in purity and tranquillity, without any of those terrible struggles with
duty and conscience which were previously considered indispensable to
bring out its intensity.
And now comes an entirely new phase in the development of George Sand's
mind. Perhaps about this time the influences immediately acting upon her
may have undergone a modification that will partly help to explain the
miracle. Her daughter, the fair Solange, is grown up and about to be
married; and the household thoughts and cares, and the tenderness of a
serious and unselfish cast, which creep to a mother's heart on such
occasions, may have shed their sweetness upon this wayward soul, and
inspired it with congenial utterances. This is mere speculation, more or
less corroborated by time and circumstance; but whatever may have been
the agencies by which the charm was wrought, certain it is that George
Sand has recently produced a work which, we will not say flippantly in
the words of the song,
"Has for once a moral,"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account