Harper's New Monthly Magazine, Vol. III, No. XVII, October 1851Various
History
Harper's New Monthly Magazine, Vol. III, No. XVII, October 1851
Various
American literature -- Periodicals; Civilization -- Periodicals; Culture -- Periodicals
We hear often of popular fallacies. Books have been written on them. But
there are also learned fallacies, and among these we know of no one more
common than that which prevails respecting the word _education_. It is
quite usual with lecturers and essayists to derive a profound
philosophical meaning from the bare etymology of the term. It is from
_educo_, they tell us, to _lead or draw out_. It means the _drawing_ out
or developing the faculties. It is the bringing out the unwrought man,
like the polished statue from the rough block of marble. All sorts of
changes are rung upon the word. With some it is the _educing_ of the
individuality, with others, of the humanity. Others again talk much of
_drawing out the ideas_, and that, too, without any previous exact
_in_struction, or the furnishing of what might be styled the prepared
material of thought--about as wise a course as to attempt to develop, or
draw _out_ the faculties of a nail-making machine, without ever thinking
of putting any well-wrought iron _into_ it. Now, all this is pedantic
nonsense. The old Roman Roundheads, from whom the term is derived, never
dreamed of any such transcendental conception. The word, in its primary
sense, simply means _nursing_, _fostering_, _rearing_. Hence is it
afterward applied to knowledge and discipline. It is educed from the
simple conception of holding the child by the hand, and leading him
forth when he first begins to walk. From the same primitive thought
comes the word _pedagogue_, which simply means, _one who leads a boy_,
and was first applied to the slave, or servant, who conducted the
Athenian child to and from school. It would, however, be hardly worth
our while to show the fallacy of this very common etymological
deduction, were it not sometimes made the ground of very false ideas.
The old view, although it have no great philosophy, will be found to be
the true one. It is to hold a child up, and lead him forth by the hand,
before you set him to walk alone by himself, under pretense of
developing his _faculties_, either of thinking or of locomotion.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account