Harvard Psychological Studies, Volume 1: Containing Sixteen Experimental Investigations from the Harvard Psychological Laboratory.
Science
Harvard Psychological Studies, Volume 1: Containing Sixteen Experimental Investigations from the Harvard Psychological Laboratory.
Psychology, Experimental
In formula 3, _W_ represents the width of a band, and _s_ the width of
the _oppositely colored_ sector. Therefore, if a disc is composed, for
example, of a red and a green sector, then
rs(green) - pr'
W(red) = ------------------ ,
r' ± r
and
rs(red) - pr'
W(green) = ------------------ ,
r' ± r
therefore, by dividing,
W(red) rs(green) - pr'
--------- = ------------------- .
W(green) rs(red) - pr'
From this last equation it is clear that unless _s_(green) = _s_(red),
_W_(red) cannot equal _W_(green). That is, if the two sectors are
unequal in width, the bands are also unequal. This was the first
feature of the illusion above noted.
Again, if one sector is larger, the oppositely colored bands will be
larger, that is, the light-colored bands will be narrower; or, in
other words, 'the narrower bands correspond in color to the larger
sector.'
Finally, if the sectors are equal, the bands must also be equal.
So far, then, the bands geometrically deduced present the same
variations as the bands observed in the illusion.
2. Secondly (p. 174, No. 2), "The faster the rod moves the broader
become the bands, but not in like proportions; broad bands widen
relatively more than narrow ones." The speed of the rod or pendulum,
in degrees per second, equals _r_. Now if _W_ increases when _r_
increases, _D_{[tau]}W_ must be positive or greater than zero for all
values of _r_ which lie in question.
Now
rs - pr'
W = --------- ,
r' ± r
and
(r' ± r)s [±] (rs - pr')
D_{[tau]}W = -------------------------- ,
(r ± r')
or reduced,
r'(s ± p)
= -----------
(r' ± r)²
Since _r'_ (the speed of the disc) is always positive, and _s_ is
always greater than _p_ (cf. p. 173), and since the denominator is a
square and therefore positive, it follows that
D_{[tau]}W > 0
or that _W_ increases if _r_ increases.
Furthermore, if _W_ is a wide band, _s_ is the wider sector. The rate
of increase of _W_ as _r_ increases is
r'(s ± p)
D_{[tau]}W = -----------
(r' ± r)²
which is larger if _s_ is larger (_s_ and _r_ being always positive).
That is, as _r_ increases, 'broad bands widen relatively more than
narrow ones.'
3. Thirdly (p. 174, No. 3), "The width of The bands increases if the
speed of the revolving disc decreases." This speed is _r'_. That the
observed fact is equally true of the geometrical bands is clear from
inspection, since in
rs - pr'
W = --------- ,
r' ± r
as _r'_ decreases, the denominator of the right-hand member decreases
while the numerator increases.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account