There are many instances of long rows of very narrow arches on
cathedral façades which are too narrow to give outward tendency, or
else they have statues within them which really take the attention
and form a series of vertical units in place of the arches. There
is also the common device of interlacing arches, where a supporting
pillar of another arch stands in the centre of every arch, thereby
always driving the attention backward and restraining it. Perhaps the
natural outward tendency of the arch-series and the necessity for its
limitation can be seen by violations of the principle. Seven of the
examples do not conform to any application of this rule and the results
are not satisfactory so far as the mere series itself is concerned.
Over the right and left doors of the Piacenza Cathedral are sections
of nine arches which end abruptly and do not even meet each other.
The Fredericksborg Schloss at Copenhagen has a row of fifteen arches
enclosing a court. These run into wings on each side, to be sure, but
all seen at once as they are and without central or end modification
they are too sharply cut off and inclined to overstep their limits. The
Loggia dei Lanzi at Florence, with its three wide arches and narrow
pillars, the William Tell Chapel in Switzerland, with only two arches,
illustrate forcibly the tendency of an arch to move outward, to appear
too wide for the superstructure and too "active" unless bound down in
some way. Four arches on the right and left of the façade of Marmonte
Church, but not across the centre, have the same unfinished effect. The
roman arch on one side of the St. Lo Cathedral façade with two gothic
arches on the other defy every principle of repetition and symmetry as
well.
From this survey of one hundred and sixty-five of arch-series we find
through a variety of means a uniformity of purpose in their treatment;
that all point to a common demand, however differently expressed,
according to the function of the series. The series must be prevented
from "running away." It must either run completely around a structure
into itself, or be balanced as a whole so that the attention which
naturally runs off the ends is driven towards the centre. This may be
accomplished by enlarging, decreasing, decorating, or pointing toward
centre of the arch by means of the obliquity of both halves of the
series. It may also be brought by enlarging, decreasing, changing the
plane of the end arches or altering the size of the limiting piers. The
essential value of the arch may be altered by narrowing it, by filling
it with something more important than itself, thereby making it only an
attendant series upon its content, by interlacing it, or by any device
that transforms or revises its outward tendency.
165 _Examples of Arch-Series._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account