"In support of that motion," and a note of growing significance appeared
in the speaker’s tone, "I argue nothing, except to ask this Court to
accept as true every word of testimony spoken by every witness heard
upon the stand this morning."
The Court looked puzzled, but the ministerial defendant went on:
"I believe the truth has been spoken by Miss Dounay—by the maid—by the
officers—and by my own friends. Yet the facts testified to may be
true,"—the minister’s voice rose,—"and the inference to which they point
be wickedly and damnably false! It is so with this case; for be it
noted that I ask your Honor to consider also that my testimony is true.
It denies no statement; it controverts no fact in the case of the
prosecution. On the contrary, it confirms them; but it also explains
them." Again the defendant’s voice was rising. "It confirms the facts,
but it utterly refutes the inference that this defendant at the bar is
guilty. Consider the entire fabric of evidence as a seamless garment of
truth, and you can dismiss the complaint with an untroubled brow.
Reason is satisfied! Justice is done!"
Hampstead paused, and a shade of apprehension came to his face, for his
eye had traveled for a moment to that massed expectancy without the
rail.
"The verdict of your Honor is to _me_"—Hampstead in his growing
earnestness had abandoned the fictional distinction between the pleader
and his client,—"of more than usual importance, for by it hangs the
verdict of the people whose interest is attested by those packed benches
yonder. Without disrespect to your Honor, I can say that I care more
for their verdict than for that of any twelve men in any jury box or any
judge upon any bench.
"But under the circumstances the whole people cannot actually judge—they
can only be my executioners. They have not heard me speak. They can not
look me in the eye, nor observe by my demeanor whether I speak like an
honest man or a contemptible fraud. They see me only through a cloud of
skillfully engendered suspicion. They hear my voice only faintly amid a
clamorous confusion of poisoned tongues. Your Honor must see for them,
and speak for them. Your Honor’s verdict will be their verdict. I
tremble for that verdict. I plead for it!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account