Heroes of science : $b Botanists, zoologists, and geologistsDuncan, P. Martin (Peter Martin)
History
Heroes of science : $b Botanists, zoologists, and geologists
Duncan, P. Martin (Peter Martin)
Naturalists
“Fossils have been long studied as great curiosities,
collected with great pains, treasured with great and at a
great expense, and shown and admired with as much pleasure
as a child’s hobby-horse is shown and admired by himself and
his playfellows, because it is pretty; and this has been done
by _thousands who have never paid the least regard to that
wonderful order and regularity with which nature has disposed
of these singular productions, and assigned to each class its
peculiar stratum_.”
Gifted in a very uncommon degree with that philosophical faith in the
generality and harmony of natural laws which is a characteristic of
discoveries in natural science, Mr. Smith was at the same time remarkably
disinclined to indulge in himself, or even to tolerate in others, mere
speculations in geology. Whatever of this nature he found in the circle
of his reading, was severely judged by a close collocation of the
hypothesis which had been advanced with the phenomena of stratification
which he had entirely established. These judgments might be erroneous
in cases which required the knowledge of other data, not then collected,
for a true and general solution; but the very unreasonableness of raising
the standard of his own discoveries in a limited region, for condemning
a speculation perhaps founded on other truths occurring elsewhere, shows
how firmly these discoveries, and the influences belonging to them, were
established and fortified in his mind. The following passage, written in
January, 1796, might have been acknowledged by the author to contain his
real opinions forty years later:—
“Therefore every man of prudence and observation who has paid the
strictest attention to mineralogy, the structure of the earth, and the
changes it has undergone, will be very cautious how he sets about to
invent a system which nature cannot conform to without having recourse
to subterraneous fires, volcanic eruptions, or uncommon convulsions, by
which every hill and dale must have been formed and every rock must have
been rent to form those chasms, which, in comparison to the strata they
are found in, are no more than sun-cracks in a clod of clay; yet such has
been the language of ingenious men, who have set their theoretical worlds
a-going without either tooth or pinion of nature’s mechanism belonging to
them.”
In October and November of this year (1796), we find him returning to the
contemplation of organic remains; discussing the circumstances which
attend the sparry substance occupying the place of the shell, which has
been removed, in the lias, and the empty cavity, where the shell was,
surrounding a loose stony cast of the interior, in the freestone (oolite).
That his mind was now actively employed in tracing out the bearings of
the extensive subject before him, will be evident from the following
extract, dated August, 1797:—
“_Locality of plants, insects, birds, etc., arises from the
nature of the strata._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account