Highways of Canadian LiteratureLogan, J. D. (John Daniel)
History
Highways of Canadian Literature
Logan, J. D. (John Daniel)
Canadian literature -- History and criticism
Quotations in this chapter, with the exception of a few lines, are from
_Later Poems_, and from _Ballads and Lyrics_, by Bliss Carman,
(McClelland & Stewart: Toronto).
CHAPTER X
Duncan Campbell Scott
INFLUENCES ON HIS WORK—OLD WORLD CULTURE—AUSTERE INTELLECTUALISM
—MUSIC AND PAINTING—ASSOCIATION WITH LAMPMAN—SCOTT, CARMAN, AND
LAMPMAN COMPARED—INFLUENCE OF ENGLISH POETS—TECHNICAL
EXCELLENCIES—REVELATION OF THE INDIAN HEART—MYSTICAL SYMBOLISM.
In the poetry of Duncan Campbell Scott there is more and finer
expression of the pageantry of Nature in Canada and of the essential
Canadian spirit than in the verse of any other Canadian poet. But,
paradoxically, the genius and poetry of Duncan Campbell Scott are also
more informed with an Old World culture and art than are the genius and
verse of any other Canadian poet. Unless the reader and the critic of D.
C. Scott’s poetry first realize that the mind and art of the poet are a
product of Canada and of the Old World, a rare commingling of Canadian
and European cultures, they will fail to understand how he is at once
the least prolific and, to give him his outstanding distinction, the
most exquisite artist of Canadian poets, not excepting Lampman and Bliss
Carman. In his poem _Frost Magic_, Scott has written the formula of his
own exquisite artistry:—
Silvered in quiet rime and with rare art.
That line, however, rather distinguishes the characteristic excellence
of his poetry on the technical side. It does not disengage the quality
which makes him unique amongst Canadian poets. His _differentia_—the
quality or power which distinguishes his poetic genius and craftsmanship
from the mind and the art of all other Canadian poets—is Style. Duncan
Campbell Scott is the one Canadian poet of whose verse it may be said
that, after the manner of the English tradition, it possesses _Style_.
Lampman’s and Carman’s, Pauline Johnson’s and Marjorie Pickthall’s,
poetry each possess a style. But in their cases the style is imitable;
it is a _manner_, original or ingenious no doubt, but not an essential
and inevitable expression, of their poets’ minds or personalities.
Duncan Campbell Scott’s poetry has style, quite as individualistic as
the others’, but it is an essential expression of his personality and
character, and is therefore inimitable, or like the man himself, is in
‘the grand manner’—which is not at all a manner but just that subtle
spiritual quality which distinguishes individuals in species. The genius
and poetry or art of Duncan Campbell Scott, then, impose on us a special
and somewhat recondite study in literary psychology.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account