Highways of Canadian LiteratureLogan, J. D. (John Daniel)
History
Highways of Canadian Literature
Logan, J. D. (John Daniel)
Canadian literature -- History and criticism
Canadian Literature is rich—not relatively but absolutely—in Dirges,
Epicedes, Elegies, Threnodies, and Elegiac Monodies. That Canadian
Elegiac Monodies, or long ‘In Memoriam’ poems inspired by the death of a
real, not a mythical or imagined, person, have genuine distinction, is
indisputable. In number they equal the monodies of English Literature;
and in manner, in variety of form, and in several qualitative
excellences they surpass the monodies of American Literature. Modern
English literature possesses five great threnodies or monodies; Milton’s
_Lycidas_, Shelley’s _Adonais_, Tennyson’s _In Memoriam_, Arnold’s
_Thyrsis_, and Swinburne’s _Ave atque Vale_. American Literature has to
its credit two fine and noble monodies: Emerson’s _Threnody_ (for his
son) and Whitman’s _When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom’d_ (for
Lincoln). Canadian Literature boasts of six threnodies or monodies,
which all enhance New World Literature and at least two of which are a
distinct contribution to the elegiac poetry of English Literature. The
Canadian monodies are Roberts’ _Ave!_ (to Shelley), Carman’s _A Seamark_
(to Stevenson), Campbell’s _Bereavement of the Fields_ (to Lampman),
Duncan Campbell Scott’s _Lines in Memory of Edmund Morris_ (a Canadian
painter), William E. Marshall’s _Brookfield_ (to R. R. MacLeod), and
James De Mille’s _Behind the Veil_ (which is sort of Dantean ‘Vision’ of
the Beloved in Heaven).
That Canadian poets should have essayed the Elegiac Monody and have
excelled in it is consistent with the genuine, the essential mood, the
spiritual attitudes of the Canadian people. For while the literary
traditions, forms, and methods of Canadian poets are English, the bases
of Canadian culture and civilization are much more New England and Scots
than English, or, in short, Puritan and Calvinistic. It was as natural
for the 19th century native-born Canadian, as it was for an 18th century
New England Puritan and Loyalist and a Scots Calvinist, to be
preoccupied with thoughts of ‘otherworldliness.’ The meaning of life and
death is almost a _congenial_ subject of reflection to the
characteristic Canadian. Fortunately the _habitat_ of the Canadian mind,
Nature in Canada, recalled Canadian poets from exclusive occupation with
spiritual prosperities and great departures to thoughts of ‘the soul’s
inherent high magnificence’ in daily mundane life and to the joys,
consolations, spiritual transports, and peace which Nature affords the
distracted human spirit. Another factor saved Canadian poets from
moralistic preachments when they were moved to express in verse their
sorrow over some great departure. They had the example of the form and
color of the English elegies, from Milton to Swinburne, to save them
from chill gravity and barren moralism. The Canadian monodists, on their
own account, also loved fine technic in verse, and strove to achieve it
according to their capacity. It was therefore natural that Canadian
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account