Highways of Canadian LiteratureLogan, J. D. (John Daniel)
History
Highways of Canadian Literature
Logan, J. D. (John Daniel)
Canadian literature -- History and criticism
In one sense all fiction is imaginative. There is, however, a species in
which pure imagination plays a much greater part than in the Community
Novel, in Historical Fiction, or in the other types discussed in this
chapter. Marjorie Pickthall’s work is the highest example of this. She
wrote, not with the reproductive imagination nor with fancy, but with
the faculty defined by Matthew Arnold as imaginative reason. Into the
texture of her fiction she wove poetic imagination and poetic
significance derived from her clear, absolute, and sympathetic
understanding of the human heart and of the hidden springs and the
meaning of existence, from her superior and inclusive sympathetic
intelligence. Thus she was enabled to write stories of the most varied
settings and of the most wildly differing characters with equal
convincingness.
_Little Hearts_ (1915), is an engaging tale of the days of ‘Bonnie
Prince Charlie’ with its conflict chiefly between loyalty to the Crown,
and fidelity to the spirit of humanity. It pictures ‘little hearts,’ men
of small fortunes, and small (as the world sees it) ambitions, in their
pathetic existence, more pathetic because of finely brave in the midst
of many both petty and heroic vicissitudes of fortune, of mean victory
and noble defeat. The novel preaches no didactic moral but it silently
teaches Christ’s philosophy of struggle and defeat—‘He that loseth his
life shall find it.’ It impresses unforgettably how little after all are
the greatest hearts, and how little we lose or gain in any defeat or
triumph which is merely earthly defeat or triumph.
_The Bridge_ (1922), has the same theme, with the pain and cruelty of
love, of unfulfilled seeking, and the final triumph of a soul that saved
itself by losing itself in inward self-knowledge and self-sacrifice. It
is set against a background of the tremendous beauty of the Great Lakes,
scenes of storm on land and water. Technically, it is farther from
perfection than _Little Hearts_; it has less structural unity, less
smoothness of style. At times the emotional situations seem overdrawn;
nor are atmosphere and setting definitively localized.
The collection of short stories—_Angel’s Shoes_ (1922)—embodies
examples of Miss Pickthall’s perfect artistry as a short story writer.
These stories are clear, vivid, colorful, and of almost the highest type
of creative imagination. They may lack, occasionally, a warmth of
humanity that is present in the work of other writers of poorer
craftsmanship.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account